Donna Ferentes said:I think there's a place for simple sentiment in popular music.
The income of the artist is essentially irrelevant to the song, just as the flaws of Dickens or Shakespeare are irrelevant to their literature.bluestreak said:Perhaps, but some over-paid git sitting at a piano trotting out a wishy-washy dirge to mutual poverty has no place anywhere, IMO.
Donna Ferentes said:The income of the artist is essentially irrelevant to the song, just as the flaws of Dickens or Shakespeare are irrelevant to their literature.
Donna Ferentes said:I thought it was modest, pared-down and made its point effectively.


Kripcat said:While we're on the topic why does everyone hate "We Built this City" by Starship so much? Ok the lyrics are a tad shit but it's got a good riff and it's not like it's lyrics are THE worst.

that Clint Black song said:If they won't show us their weapons
we might have to show them ours.
Well of course it may be some time before I can aspire to your standards of commentary and courtesy, but nevertheless it may be in order both to question your choice, this being in the nature of debate, and to observe that my second comment was, in fact, not directly about the song referred to, but referred ironically to my first.Dubversion said:well that's marvellous. I don't, hence my comment. Which perhaps deserved a different response - or even no response at all - rather than your childish little post
Donna Ferentes said:blah blah blah blah blah blah blah
There aren't that many songs I actively dislike - just a lot that I'd prefer not to hear.

Donna Ferentes said:Hmmm, Dubversion. Likes to express his opinions, doesn't like other people disagreeing. Small fish, small pond.
constitutes such a disagreement.CharlieAddict said:bohemian rhapsody
Donna Ferentes said:If that smiley doesn't constitute scepticism, what does?
It's possible that I may have felt this about your choice of course.Dubversion said:tiresome as ever.
dash_two said:The one with a male singer that goes 'I feeeel soooooo-eeee-siiiiiiidal, soooooo-eeee-siiiiiiidal, soooooo-eeee-siiiiiiidal' etc. Just my current bugbear, there'll be another one along shortly.
You should be. The blatant disregard for the basics of architecture and town planning in that song is unforgiveably irresponsible.May Kasahara said:I love that song, and I'm not afraid to say so![]()
Donna Ferentes said:It's possible that I may have felt this about your choice of course.
It's the thing about rock 'n' roll commentary - it tends not to think of itself as a two-way process. The cool slag off the non-cool and everybody admires them for it.


Dubversion said:Oh, I see. I - as the 'cool' person in your analysis - am simply acting out an age-old role in slagging off the 'non-cool' in this scenario, seeking to gain admiration?
Glad we've sorted that out then
is it not possible that i just don't like the song? and are you sure EVERYONE admires me for it? bit sloppy, no?
moomoo said:I quite like Imagine Dub, but that won't surprise you.![]()
