How about compulsory for a year or two but optional thereafter? I would have liked that.
When I first went to secondary school I was very annoyed about which things were compulsory for the first two years. Didn't mind the compulsory French, English, History, Geography, Maths and so on, but I was furious that it was compulsory to have classes in cooking and sewing. For girls only!



Boys had compulsory woodwork and metalwork and I daresay they might have been annoyed about that. I don't know. Compulsory Gaelic would have been much more fun. And more useful than stupid fish pie.
And yes, I am still annoyed. That was in 1973. Is it time for me to stop bearing this grudge?