JoePolitix
Gone
Xipe blames the democrats and aids the coup plotters
Your arguments, the ones that are remotely coherent that is, have been refuted. One example – your claim that Venezuela’s Electoral Council is simply a government front organisation was completely rejected by international observers like the European Union Observer Mission and the Carter Institute. Both organisations accepted that the CNE had bent over backwards to meet opposition demands and it is obvious to anybody that the stated reason of the opposition parties that the CNE could not be trusted was merely an excuse for them to pull out of an election they would be humiliated in.
It’s true that the separation of powers in Venezuela is quite weak – like in the US and UK – but its not as weak as you imply. This was illustrated by the link I provided which shows that only days ago Venezuela’s Supreme Court ruled the Vice-Minister of Foreign Relations for North America - a loyal Chavatista - is unfit to exercise public office, rather illustrates that judicial independence is still alive and well in Venezuela.
You locate the blame for the difficulties Venezuela is facing with Chavez who you say has a “questionable attitude to democracy (!)”. Yet who is to blame for the fact that the country’s elected body, the NA, is solely made up of the pro Chavez parties? Could it be the bankrupt neo-liberal parties who spent their years in office selling Venezuela’s assets to the highest bidder, massacring street protesters and excluding the majority of the population from politics? Could it be these same parties who have aided a fascistic coup, organised lockouts and attempted to disrupt Venezuela’s democratic life at every conjuncture? Was it not these parties that of their own volition boycotted last years democratic elections?
The fact that you blame the leadership of the Bolivarian revolution for any democratic deficits that Venezuela might suffer whilst neglecting the role of the imperialist backed opposition objectively makes your contributions to this thread pro-imperialist and reactionary despite your wining to the contrary and your insincere applauding of the revolution’s achievements.
Xipe Totec said:If you want me to engage with you any further you can answer my question:
Exactly where have my arguments been disproved?
Your arguments, the ones that are remotely coherent that is, have been refuted. One example – your claim that Venezuela’s Electoral Council is simply a government front organisation was completely rejected by international observers like the European Union Observer Mission and the Carter Institute. Both organisations accepted that the CNE had bent over backwards to meet opposition demands and it is obvious to anybody that the stated reason of the opposition parties that the CNE could not be trusted was merely an excuse for them to pull out of an election they would be humiliated in.
It’s true that the separation of powers in Venezuela is quite weak – like in the US and UK – but its not as weak as you imply. This was illustrated by the link I provided which shows that only days ago Venezuela’s Supreme Court ruled the Vice-Minister of Foreign Relations for North America - a loyal Chavatista - is unfit to exercise public office, rather illustrates that judicial independence is still alive and well in Venezuela.
You locate the blame for the difficulties Venezuela is facing with Chavez who you say has a “questionable attitude to democracy (!)”. Yet who is to blame for the fact that the country’s elected body, the NA, is solely made up of the pro Chavez parties? Could it be the bankrupt neo-liberal parties who spent their years in office selling Venezuela’s assets to the highest bidder, massacring street protesters and excluding the majority of the population from politics? Could it be these same parties who have aided a fascistic coup, organised lockouts and attempted to disrupt Venezuela’s democratic life at every conjuncture? Was it not these parties that of their own volition boycotted last years democratic elections?
The fact that you blame the leadership of the Bolivarian revolution for any democratic deficits that Venezuela might suffer whilst neglecting the role of the imperialist backed opposition objectively makes your contributions to this thread pro-imperialist and reactionary despite your wining to the contrary and your insincere applauding of the revolution’s achievements.



)
