So we lost our over 40s cup semi-final on Saturday afternoon, 1-1 AET, 5-4 on penalties. It's since transpires that 2 of the opposing team were significantly younger than the rules allow, as you need to be 40 on the October 1 of the season in question, i.e. last October. Our manager has lodged an appeal with the AFA. Can't decide whether I think that's right or not. Thoughts?