Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

The Urban Writing Thread

Are you in?


  • Total voters
    74
In the face of the Peoples decision I shall post under a psuedonym, upon the blog provided by Comrade Upsidedownwalrus
 
monthly. I believe shifty proposed that the previous months winner set the topic, and while I worry that 'First past the post' might be a better system, I see no massive issues with her idea.

You've confused me. 'First past the post', isn't that what is on the table already... That the 'first past the post' selects the next topic? :confused:
 
You've confused me. 'First past the post', isn't that what is on the table already... That the 'first past the post' selects the next topic? :confused:

ah, perhaps if I'd said 'first to mention a topic gets to set the topic'.

which is another way of doing it. I'm happy with winner sets the topic though.
 
May one suggest, being a writer by trade, published in the short story genre and, given that this is a blog and not on Urban, that we bump up the word limit to 3000 words or less (nobody has to use all 3000 words, obviously) as 1500 isn't always enough to make for a really meaty story?

Like I said,m nobody need actually use 3000 words, but it does make for a little more in the way of creative freedom if the opportunity to do so is available.
 
OK, so can i set the first topic, seeing as I made the blog?

Thats only cause you already have something to submit isn't it? ;)
Nah, seems fair though, nice on the blog :)

ah, perhaps if I'd said 'first to mention a topic gets to set the topic'.

which is another way of doing it. I'm happy with winner sets the topic though.

I see what you mean now, the only reservation I have with the winner choosing the topic is that may incur some advantage. Tailoring the topic for themselves etc. Perhaps thats the spoils of victory though, dunno..



e2a - 3 votes and the motion is passed sir, your topic?
 
Thats only cause you already have something to submit isn't it? ;)
Nah, seems fair though, nice on the blog :)



I see what you mean now, the only reservation I have with the winner choosing the topic is that may incur some advantage. Tailoring the topic for themselves etc. Perhaps thats the spoils of victory though, dunno..

How about a monthly poll (anonymous, naturally) among the contributors to select the next month's topic?

It'd remove any possibility of any one person being able to choose a topic that automatically favours them and should help generate a good spread of subjects and different winners.
 
How about a monthly poll (anonymous, naturally) among the contributors to select the next month's topic?

It'd remove any possibility of any one person being able to choose a topic that automatically favours them and should help generate a good spread of subjects and different winners.

Sounds good.

If your entering mr 'Published short story man' I think you should have a handicap... You've got to write with your foot or summink!! :p :D
 
Sounds good.

If your entering mr 'Published short story man' I think you should have a handicap... You've got to write with your foot or summink!! :p :D

Handicap, eh?

Well, being Urban's resident Quintessential Studmuffin and all-round Captain Charisma, I shall see no problems in facing up to such constraints.

Onward, good people of Urban, onward I say, to a bright and shing future of creative GLORY!!!!!!!!!!
 
How about a monthly poll (anonymous, naturally) among the contributors to select the next month's topic?

It'd remove any possibility of any one person being able to choose a topic that automatically favours them and should help generate a good spread of subjects and different winners.

I have no objections to whatever method of topic-choosing is proposed. Let us not get bogged down in procedural details, however, comrades.

Forward with the Peoples Writing Contest.
 
So, to clarify. We seem to have lost Shifty for the moment.

1. Anything up to 3000 word limit.
2. Fresh topics will be decided by anonymous Urban poll.
3. Uppy'downy'walrus to pick the first topic.
4. All entries must be submitted anonymously.
5. A toblerone for the monthly victor.


What else???
 
am still here, no objections so far
what about a deadline? i say around te 25th to give people time to read and vote before the end of the month
 
am still here, no objections so far
what about a deadline? i say around te 25th to give people time to read and vote before the end of the month

Good idea, Madam.

That should give folk enough time and encourages folk not to be tardy in their writing.
 
i don't know what a 1500 word post looks like, let me go ask mrs quoad :p

:D :D

I think it would be better to leave it open, no number of words limit, and both prose or poetry

I would enter if I felt inspired by the theme and had no limits imposed in terms of the number of words. Some themes might inspire someone to write a novel! Why restrict them? (also anyone who can write a novel in month deserves some form of recognition!!!)
 
:D :D

I think it would be better to leave it open, no number of words limit, and both prose or poetry

I would enter if I felt inspired by the theme and had no limits imposed in terms of the number of words. Some themes might inspire someone to write a novel! Why restrict them? (also anyone who can write a novel in month deserves some form of recognition!!!)

They have NanoWriMo for that.

I think a tight limit a) aids creativity

and
b) makes it readable. for a crowd not onto taking on a whole book as a read
 
Back
Top Bottom