Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

The Left is a failure in the UK - but why? - A Friday poll for the less political too

why has the left failed?


  • Total voters
    72
Only because they're already crushed now as it is. I don't know if you've noticed, but to all extents and purposes there IS no effective organised labour movement in this country anymore.
I must have imagined the recent council, teacher and oil worker strikes

Change the record, you depressive prat.
 
Exactly. In a world of, say, $500 oil, anyone making their own fuels could be labelled as a 'terrorist against the state' and disappeared quite easily. Same goes for organising your own food supply.
You've lost it too
 
Don't forget what is happening in Italy:

From the Guardian:

The prime minister-elect's closest ally, Umberto Bossi, the Northern League leader, kept up the intimidating rhetoric, arriving for the first session of Italy's parliament warning of violence if the centre-left did not go along with his plans for federalism.

"I don't know what the left wants [but] we are ready," he told reporters. "If they want conflicts, I have 300,000 men always on hand."

Remember that Berlusconi is / was admired by Blair....
 
nurembergRally.jpg


Hyde Park, 2009.
 
Suffering fuck.


Exhibit A, ladies and gentlemen.

suffering is what one has to do with tedious cunts like you :-)

so - there is no class division any more ?- hospitals and schools are not being flogged off? workers pensions, rights and wages are not being attacked? the rich arn't getting richer? the poor arn't getting poorer? its all a leftie fantasy... (oh and the working class is a gibbering mass of idiots with no potential power - I've got to admit if they were all like poster and you - then you two would have a point..)

oh ell not as big a fantasy as your personal 'anarchist' dream of having any relevance at all. If the 'left' is outdated - the 'anarchist' are completely dead in the water :)
 
I must have imagined the recent council, teacher and oil worker strikes

Change the record, you depressive prat.

Won their demands, have they?

As I said - there's no EFFECTIVE labour movement in this country. A harmless and tokenistic, let-off-steam-for-a-few-activists one, maybe.
 
You've lost it too
You reckon?
I'm VERY worried about the future energy supply for the world. Oil looks to have peaked, and Gas isn't far away. As these things start to decline, it will become very obvious how fragile the system is. Expect inflation, rationing, war and shortages of food.

Go look at any study of world water supplies. You'll see that aquifers that took 1000s of years to fill are being drained empty, rivers no longer reach the sea, water sources are being polluted.

Topsoil similarly takes 100s of years to be created and cannot be synthesised. Industrial agriculture robs soil of nutrients and erodes it to be washed into the sea. The United States has lost half of its topsoil since 1960.

The population of the world is growing, and they are being fed and powered by resources that are being exhausted faster than they are being created, or by resources that cannot be created or substituted.

That club of rome stuff from the 70s - they were right, they just had the timing wrong.

PS: I'm thinking about 50-year timescales, not eg. the next general election
 
This thread is fucking funny.

This country is very well set up for a slide into fascism if you ask me.

Opening the door for fascism may well be Blair's legacy. The utter cunt.

This is why people think the left is a joke when comments like this are made.
 
Won their demands, have they?
Looks like the oil workers did. Dunno about the other lot, but those struggles need support and strategies to spread and make them effective not prats like you who have basically lost it pretending they don't even exist
 
Won their demands, have they?

As I said - there's no EFFECTIVE labour movement in this country. A harmless and tokenistic, let-off-steam-for-a-few-activists one, maybe.

as opposed to a supine whimpering coward in the corner, saying 'its all hopeless' who puts his neck on the floor just waiting for what he considers the inevitable jack-boot.

idiot - the problem with you cowards is you don't know how hard it will actually get - 'holiday in cambodia' and all that - but millions of other folk - luckily - don't give up the ability to survive and struggle
 
You reckon?
I'm VERY worried about the future energy supply for the world. Oil looks to have peaked, and Gas isn't far away. As these things start to decline, it will become very obvious how fragile the system is. Expect inflation, rationing, war and shortages of food.

It's another left classic innit.

"Peak oil"? WTF is that?
 
Innit. Quite a few hysterical soldiers in the trench. It'll be revolver time soon :D

Fear not Urban's masses will rise before fascism can raise its ugly head in this sceptred isle, they'll organise an offline event or something.
 
Looks like the oil workers did. Dunno about the other lot, but those struggles need support and strategies to spread and make them effective not prats like you who have basically lost it pretending they don't even exist

Sorry, but l'll believe in an induistrial dispute that's WON by the workers (and not either ignored, sold-out, or quietly reneged-upon by the bosses when the fuss dies down) when I see one.

Part of the left's biggest failure of recent times is it's bizarre retreat into over-stated, hollow triumphalism and baseless optimism. Constant clutching at straws.
 
You reckon?
I'm VERY worried about the future energy supply for the world. Oil looks to have peaked, and Gas isn't far away. As these things start to decline, it will become very obvious how fragile the system is. Expect inflation, rationing, war and shortages of food.

Go look at any study of world water supplies. You'll see that aquifers that took 1000s of years to fill are being drained empty, rivers no longer reach the sea, water sources are being polluted.

Topsoil similarly takes 100s of years to be created and cannot be synthesised. Industrial agriculture robs soil of nutrients and erodes it to be washed into the sea. The United States has lost half of its topsoil since 1960.

The population of the world is growing, and they are being fed and powered by resources that are being exhausted faster than they are being created, or by resources that cannot be created or substituted.

That club of rome stuff from the 70s - they were right, they just had the timing wrong.

PS: I'm thinking about 50-year timescales, not eg. the next general election
Not got time really for this now, but I agree with most of that. I just found your prognosis of the political corrolary to it was way off and lacked a basic faith/realism in the fact that people will resist the effects of crisis in progressive ways, as they already are in many countries around the world. I felt you jumped straight to some sort of comic book catastrophic political landscape. You should study the seeds of changes that exist in people's responses as much as you do the basic man/nature crisis
 
Sorry, but l'll believe in an induistrial dispute that's WON by the workers (and not either ignored, sold-out, or quietly reneged-upon by the bosses when the fuss dies down) when I see one.

Part of the left's biggest failure of recent times is it's bizarre retreat into over-stated, hollow triumphalism and baseless optimism.

'There has never been a better time to be a socialist' has to be one of the most hollow and dishonest statements I've seen in years.

Mind you, it does come from the SWP.
 
This thread is fucking funny.





This is why people think the left is a joke when comments like this are made.

People think the left is a joke because they don't understand how society is organised and they are far too complacent and optimistic about the political situation and their own future prospects. You seem no different to the rest.

The country is not fascist at the moment, and it would be foolish to claim that it was. There is enormous cause for concern in terms of the direction its headed though, and the lack of any opposition to it. As hs already been mentioned, look at Italy - bona fide fascism in political office once again. There's nothing magical about Britain that means it won't happen here, personally I think the British are rather prone to it.
 
Sorry, but l'll believe in an induistrial dispute that's WON by the workers (and not either ignored, sold-out, or quietly reneged-upon by the bosses when the fuss dies down) when I see one.

Part of the left's biggest failure of recent times is it's bizarre retreat into over-stated, hollow triumphalism and baseless optimism. Constant clutching at straws.

As opposed to your just "bizarre retreat"?
 
I'm glad you're giving the issue your full and careful consideration.

Wow talk about this thread proving the point made by the OP.

thats right...

remind me what the 'point' was again

do give us you 'insight' (including 'solutions')...
 
Not got time really for this now, but I agree with most of that. I just found your prognosis of the political corrolary to it was way off and lacked a basic faith/realism in the fact that people will resist the effects of crisis in progressive ways, as they already are in many countries around the world. I felt you jumped straight to some sort of comic book catastrophic political landscape. You should study the seeds of changes that exist in people's responses as much as you do the basic man/nature crisis
I'm usually so optimistic too...
Maybe I'm just having a grumpy day :)
 
People think the left is a joke because they don't understand how society is organised and they are far too complacent and optimistic about the political situation and their own future prospects. You seem no different to the rest.

Look at you, Boris may win and the tories take over a load of councils and you're worried that the third reich is going to kick your doors down. The tories aren't going to do anything that new labour wouldn't (this close to a general election, they'd ruin their chances of winning if they went out on a wing and did something daft).

Italy is a vastly different country politcally to ours, I don't presume we're some magical kingdom that is immune from the worst but for god's sake man, have some faith in people. Even the bluest of tories isn't going to suddenly going to adopt fasc' ideologies.

Britain isn't some autarky that can survive on it's own, even the BNP know that.
 
Back
Top Bottom