Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

The Controversial Pie Thread

EastEnder said:
side, not sides....:mad:

Don't be fooled by PieEye's non-circular abominations!!!! :mad:
:) I put a / there, purely to avoid any discrimination of the grammer crew
thank you very much,,, :mad: ;)
 
PieEye said:
An oft ignored piece of cautionary advice. I pity the fool that does not put a hole in the pie.

(
pie.jpg
 
Oh dear . . . I am afraid you are all crumbling the wrong crust. A pie is not defined by a pastry top or sides at all. Rather, it is what's under the lid that's important.

Traditionally, a pie has many ingredients (a medley or jumble), whereas a pastry has only one.

Connected to this idea is the word 'pie' for a jumble of type, and possibly the word magpie, to refer to a bird that collects a jumble of objects.

There is also a connection to the idea of "pie" is a medley that is somehow indiscriminate, and/or a product that is poor quality - which, to me, makes sense since such a medley of ingredients in years gone by were probably cheap cuts or leftovers only really fit for dogs.
 
Dissident Junk in with a controversial 11th hour barrage of pie based fact!

A meddle and a jumbly of contents? This has thrown me.

Can we have a source for this statement please? - and if it was your nan that told you I'm afraid it won't wash :mad:
 
Dissident Junk said:
Oh dear . . . I am afraid you are all crumbling the wrong crust. A pie is not defined by a pastry top or sides at all. Rather, it is what's under the lid that's important.
And the lid has to be circular.

Otherwise it won't fit onto the circular edge of the pie.

:cool:
 
Dissident Junk said:
.....

Connected to this idea is the word 'pie' for a jumble of type, and possibly the word magpie, to refer to a bird that collects a jumble of objects.
.....


that's wrong for a start - the magpie is so called because it is black and white or "pied" - like the pied wagtail and, indeed the pied piper although the latter has come to be portayed as any two colours rather than the strict black and white meaning ....
 
Wolfie said:
that's wrong for a start - the magpie is so called because it is black and white or "pied" - like the pied wagtail and, indeed the pied piper although the latter has come to be portayed as any two colours rather than the strict black and white meaning ....

So quick to lambast . . . I said "connected to".

The connection is in the old latin word "pica" for "magpie"

For full etmological run down on the connection between magpie, text and pie: http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?search=pica&searchmode=none
 
:rolleyes:

the elephants have painted their bollocks red

to look like cherries

which the monkeys are eating

which make the elephants trumpet in pain.

see?
 
Back
Top Bottom