
In Bloom said:Imagine's not that bad, it's pretty dull and politically shallow, but still kind of sweet.
Fair playDubversion said:Nonsense.
Imagine if, when you were a kid - aged about, i dunno, 11 - you were asked to write a poem about 'peace'. And imagine that you did and since you were only 11 it was full of platitudes and triteness but everyone thought it was sweet for an 11 year old, and kind of wise, y'know, FOR AN 11 YEAR OLD. And imagine that your mum was dead proud and kept the poem in a keepsake box for years and then it was your wedding day, say, and as a wedding gift your mum got the tune set to music by an ageing and barely competent retired music teacher who set it to a school-hymn style dirge. And imagine that it was then played AT YOUR WEDDING.
That's how ashamed Lennon should be about the fucking song.


so what, in your opinion, is a good song? if you don't mind me asking.Dubversion said:Nonsense.
Imagine if, when you were a kid - aged about, i dunno, 11 - you were asked to write a poem about 'peace'. And imagine that you did and since you were only 11 it was full of platitudes and triteness but everyone thought it was sweet for an 11 year old, and kind of wise, y'know, FOR AN 11 YEAR OLD. And imagine that your mum was dead proud and kept the poem in a keepsake box for years and then it was your wedding day, say, and as a wedding gift your mum got the tune set to music by an ageing and barely competent retired music teacher who set it to a school-hymn style dirge. And imagine that it was then played AT YOUR WEDDING.
That's how ashamed Lennon should be about the fucking song.
Pavlik said:so what, in your opinion, is a good song? if you don't mind me asking.
You said Imagine is shite. Fair enough but I'm just curious to hear what you think is a good example of a song.Dubversion said:That's a bit of a dumb fucking question, isn't it?
What, ANY good song ever? and from that, you're going to reach what conclusion precisely?
oh dearPavlik said:You said Imagine is shite. Fair enough but I'm just curious to hear what you think is a good example of a song.

Pavlik said:You said Imagine is shite. Fair enough but I'm just curious to hear what you think is a good example of a song.

I'm interested in other people's opinions.Dubversion said:Why?
Pavlik said:I'm interested in other people's opinions.
I wasn't going to slag off your choice. I was genuinely interested to hear what you think is a good song. Maybe I might like it too.Dubversion said:But don't you think it's a rather ridiculous question?

Neva said:Imagine is okay. I think if it was written by someone like Vashti Bunyan then Dub probably wouldn't hate it with such a passion.
Pavlik said:It's very easy to slag somehing off. I'd just like to hear something positive.
Pavlik said:It may not be a great song but there are some thought provoking ideas in there.
Because they're a religion. Fucking hell, how difficult is it?northernhoard said:How the fuck can a religion that is based on death whose key symbol is a bloke suffering on a cross be bothered about something they claim to be anti-religious
Dubversion said:You're right. Calling it a "dreadful song" is absurd.
Calling it a shitdribbling piece of turgid shite with mindlessly facile lyrics and a "tune" so plodding and ugly that it makes you want to gouge out your eye with a spoon just so you can use it for an earplug is much more sensible.
It's an embarassment, a disgrace, a sack of shit.
I normally refrain from saying things like "So and So is music for people who don't like music" and things like that, but I make an exception for Imagine.
If you like it, you're a feeble minded cunt. It really is that simple, I'm afraid.

And it has a lovely video.Hollis said:The lyrics.. combined with the tune and the performance.. fantastic song! One of the best.
![]()