People who've made great music in two different BANDS

[Spark]

the dirty three - can't remember which one(s) were in the Bad Seeds though

Also, James Johnston from Gallon Drunk is now in the Bad Seeds

 

[Spark]

do people who are actually in one band, but have guested on another band's tracks count?

 

[Spark]

kathleen hanna - bikini kill and le tigre

 

[futha]

do people who are actually in one band, but have guested on another band's tracks count?

im not sure. if so then every single grime/hop hop artists ever. if they count as 'bands'.

 

[kerb]

do people who are actually in one band, but have guested on another band's tracks count?

i dont reckon thats what the op meant. otherwise people like Snoop would have been in dozens of bands

and thats just schnizel

(beat me to it ^^^... you're right though. they're not really bands are they?)

 

[futha]

im not sure. techinically they are a group of 'musicians' i guess. does that mean its a band?

 

[Dubversion]

if that's the rule, the whole thread becomes meaningless because of session men. Think of the Motown and Stax house bands - they played on fucking everything

 

[futha]

yeah true. so would you say kevin shields was a valid one as i think he only played live with primal scream?

 

[Magic Sam]

Ritchie Blackmore- The Outlaws/ Deep Purple/ Rainbow/ Blackmore's Night.

Ok some of these could be stretching the definition of the word "great" but each had it's moments.

 

[Riff]

Jack White - White Stripes/Raconteurs
Didz Hammond - Cooper Temple Clause/Dirty Pretty Things
Slash - G n' R/Slash's Snakepit/Velvet Revolver (settles that one!)
Scott Gorham - Stone Temple Pilots/Velvet Revolver
Tom Morello - RATM/Audioslave
Mike Bordin - Faith No More/Black Sabbath

 

[saucisson]

terry hall, neville staples and lynden golding
specials and then fun boy three.....(fun boy three are ripe for reappraisal imo)

and then terry was in the colourfield who had a couple of great songs.

 

[Maggot]

Maggots just a grumpy old man and ever since I posted that picture of his heart being broken when Charlton scored an equaliser to send Palace out of the premier league he's been disagreeing with everything I say

That picture was taken during a Palace - Southampton game. We played Charlton the following week.

 

[Termite Man]

Scott Gorham - Stone Temple Pilots/Velvet Revolver

It helps if you get his name right

 

[Termite Man]

That picture was taken during a Palace - Southampton game. We played Charlton the following week.

Well it's still a damn funny picture !

 

[Buds and Spawn]

Terry Bickers - The House of Love, Levitation

Christian Hayes - Ring, Cardiacs, Levitation, Dark Star

Dick Lucas - Subhumans, Culture Shock, Citizen Fish

Julian Cope - Teardrop Explodes, and er... Julian Cope

Robin Proper-Sheppard - The God Machine, Sophia

Margaret Fiedler - Ultra Vivid Scene, Moonshake, Laika

 

[D'wards]

How can we have got this far into the thread without:-

Stephen Malkmus - Pavement/Silver Jews/The Jicks/Solo efforts

or

Vince Clarke - Depeche Mode/Erasure/Yazoo

How could you fellas have forgotten them?

 

[Orang Utan]

Mick Harris anyone? Certain Beyond All Reasonable Doubt, Defecation, Equations Of Eternity, Extreme Noise Terror, Flux , Hygiene, M.J. Harris & Martyn Bates, Matera, Napalm Death, PainKiller, Praxis, Scorn, Trace Decay, Unseen Terror, Clang, Fret, Lull, Monrella, Quoit, Scorn, The Weakener

 

[Sunspots]

Maceo Parker ~The JBs/Funkadelic/Parliament
Fred Wesley ~ The JBs/Funkadelic/Parliament
Bootsy Collins ~ The JBs/Funkadelic/Parliament
Catfish Collins ~ The JBs/Funkadelic/Parliament
Klaus Dinger ~ Kraftwerk/Neu!/La Dusseldorf
Michael Rother ~ Kraftwerk/Neu!/Harmonia
Jared Warren ~ Tight Bro's From Way Back When/Big Business/Melvins
Mick Avory ~ The Rolling Stones/The Kinks
Michael Dempsey ~ The Associates/The Cure
Thighpaulsandra ~ Coil/Julian Cope/Spiritualized
Mark Stewart ~ The Pop Group/The Maffia
Kid Congo ~ The Gun Club/The Cramps
Patricia Morrison ~ The Gun Club/Sisters Of Mercy
Brant Bjork ~ Kyuss/Fu Manchu
Brendan O'Hare ~ Teenage Fanclub/Mogwai
William Carruthers ~ Spacemen 3/Spiritualized
Mark Lanegan ~ Screaming Trees/QOTSA/The Twilight Singers
Mike Watt ~ The Minutemen/fIREHOSE/The Stooges
Jonathan Donahue ~ Mercury Rev/The Flaming Lips
David Thomas ~ Rocket From The Tombs/Pere Ubu
Billy Childish ~ The Milkshakes/Thee Mighty Caesars/The Buff Medways
Ian Svenonius ~ The Nation of Ulysses/The Make-Up
Heidi Range ~ Atomic Kitten/The Sugababes/GG Allin Band

 

[kained&able]

Okay first danm you drew for getting chris cornell in i thought(was shocked) that i might get that down first.

Kirst nolhvevefjf was never in foo fighters. Nate mendel has always been thier bass player. The neptunes ain't a band they are a production duo, they don't perform as the neptunes and have never released anything other then clones as the neptunes.

Chris shiflet- No use for a name/foo fighters
Nick ovileri- jyruss/queens of stoneage
Twiggy Ramerez- Marilyn Manson/ A perfect circle
Melissa auf de mar- Hole/Smashing Pumpkins
Maynard James Keenan- A perfect circle/tool
Travis Barker- Blink182/box car racer/ transplants
Matt Sorum- The cult/ Guns n roses/slash's snamkepit/ velvet revolver
Dr dre- N.W.A/ The firm
Vinne paz- Jedi mind tricks/ army of pharoahs


that will do.


dave

 

[upsidedownwalrus]

Lou Barlow - Dinosaur Jr and Sebadoh

Damn it I was just about to say Stephen Malkmus but d/wards beat me to it!

Silver Jews are a great band.

 

[Dubversion]

Kid Congo ~ The Gun Club/The Cramps

,, The Bad Seeds..

Billy Childish ~ The Milkshakes/Thee Mighty Caesars/The Buff Medways

Thee Headcoats, Thee Pop Rivets, The Musicians of the British Empire etc etc etc

 

[Sunspots]

,, The Bad Seeds..

I left that out 'cos somebody (-probably Savage Henry!) had already mentioned it.

Thee Headcoats, Thee Pop Rivets, The Musicians of the British Empire etc etc etc

Yep, I honestly nearly just put 'Billy Childish ~ every band EVER!'...

 

[Sunspots]

Apart from brief stints onstage, I'm surprised that the Elephant 6 collective isn't brimming full of moonlighters and multi-band members. I always imagined all the various line-ups were all bleeding into each other, but it seems not. A confusing scene!

Jeff Mangum ~ Olivia Tremor Control/Neutral Milk Hotel

Will Cullen Hart ~ Olivia Tremor Control/Circulatory System

Bill Doss ~ Olivia Tremor Control/Apples In Stereo

And yes, they're all 'great bands'. -Well, I think so, anyway...

 

[stavros]

Guest spots don't count, and neither do producers unless they were actually members of bands too like Eno was.

 

[Sunspots]

Guest spots don't count, and neither do producers unless they were actually members of bands too like Eno was.

You tell 'em!