Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Oscars 2016

Lowest viewing figures for years - Al Sharpton taken credit by claiming it was as a rsult of his boycott, but on Guardian Podcast they reasoned it was more "normal" non-racist people being sick of the whole #oscarsowhite thing and the Oscars being news for weeks that people just sodded off the whole thing in the end.
 
I'm not about to tell others what to be offended by (or not), but to me that joke was playing on the cliche of lazy stereotyping (Asians are good at math) to set up the follow up joke regarding the use of slave labour and how everyone is complicit in it because they desire the latest gadgets / toys.

It was a joke intended to make the (mostly rich) audience feel uncomfortable and as far as I can tell worked. Some of the reporting since seems to be the backlash against being made to feel guilty.

But you're not after a debate, just stirring as usual.

I think you have to look at the comedian and the overall style.

Ali G makes himself the brunt of the gag, I'm saying stupid shit because i think I'm black but as I'm not I get it wrong by buying into stereotypes. I'm the idiot.
His asian joke was whats known as swerve humour. You think I'm going to say something outrageous but swerve I said something else.

Chris Rock however plays the Ain't i so clever pointing shit out to you folks humour.
The overall intention was say hey the only part the Asians played in the Oscars this year was behind the scenes, I'm going to point this out to you in a deliberately offensive manner (Deliberate stereotype), you guys can't complain because you rich american's benefit from sweatshop electronics (another stereotype but this time i believe he means it).

He fell into lazy stereotyping three time. Sweatshops, the Chinese are good at maths and that lots of accountants are Jewish. By the way there are Chinese Jews,Google The Kaifeng Jews. I'm sure he didn't know this at the time and just thought calling a Chinese child a Jewish name would be amusing. (Although I'll be honest i only found this out a couple of weeks ago and thanks to BBC 1).

Maybe those in the audience can't complain but did he forget the Oscars are broadcast globally to those who can complain and are directly offended at the stereotyping as it affects them daily.

Jumping to conclusions about my motives again. I'm surprised Urbanists aren't all millionaires considering everyone thinks they are a mind reader.
We pointed out in somewhere else that Oscars diversity wasn't just about black but asian and latino under-representation too if you remember. Urban discussed it before the Oscars and even said how the Asians had it worse than black actors. I was part of that discussion before Chris Rock's joke so no I'm not just stirring it up after the party.

Oscars diversity and inclusion was a high profile issue, chose to highlight 'black lives' throughout and yet when it came to including other groups to the topic made one token offensive mention. Maybe if other bits had been included in the show it could have been waved past but as it was there only mention. Nope just not good enough.
 
Last edited:
there was, rocks most annoying flaw and its not confined to just him as a comedian, a bit of a classist slur. A do-er or don't-ers bit. You won't have spotted that in your quest to hunt hypocrisy. I only skimmed the transcript of his opening routine tbh because like fuck am I watching the oscar ceremony. Nearly all award ceremonies are boring and shit now.
 
The majority of asians I've seen talking about it on twitter are angry as hell about those pieces. In fact, I can't think of a single asian person I've seen on there who wasn't. They feel it was racist. I accept the scope of tweets I or anyone else sees is just a drop in the ocean. But there you go.
 
A good friend's East Asian and an actor (more stage than film but think this applies to both). The lack of colour blind casting is a massive issue for her and other E Asian actors. She rarely gets auditions for things that are colour blind, meaning she often ends up playing sex workers/DVD sellers if she wants to work. :rolleyes:

It's even worse for some of her friends who're mixed race -- not viewed as looking E Asian enough for those roles but not white enough to play 'white' roles.
 
My friend was shortlisted for an Oscar this year for his documentary film 3.5 minutes.. I'm not sure if he pulled it or it wasn't nominated but he is currently filming in a rainforest..
 
JJ Abrams introduces racial quotas at his company

JJ Abrams' Bad Robot introduces diversity quota

I'm not sure about the whole positive discrimination/quotas as a way of redressing that balance. If you are non-white and get a job due to this system some it was always be an elephant in the room - easy accusation to level that you got the job by tokenism rather than merit. And office politics can be very cruel.
 
There is a section on race and Hollywood in this 1968 documentary 'Black History - Lost, Stolen or Strayed'
 
Back
Top Bottom