One Tribe One Country

[THINK!]

Your solution for ethnic independent states still doesn't end ethnic conflict though does it? Say if Scotland broke away from the U.K but still kept an ethnic diverse population of Pakistanis, Chinese etc, there is still ethnic conflict and division. Sure it's not armed conflict but there's still discrimination and that's where armed conflict arises from.

Anyway you haven't really answered anyone's questions or countered anyone's evidence proving your idea won't work. All you've done is give answers that contradict the OP or just said "And your solution to such and such?" or "Do you support so and so's struggle for independence?" what's your solution to these problems? other than your rather mental idea of dividing the world even further.

dividing the World??
or sharing the World mor fairly and giving people the chance to run their own lives/affairs.
You hav a house and a garden and so does your neighbour and you (plural) aren't at each throats all day trying to kill each other (mostly) are you.

 

[Doctor Carrot]

Seeing as you're so unwilling to answer any bits of evidence that have proved your idea won't work, even the most startlingly obvious one (Israel/Palestine) here's one for ya.

What would you do about Cyprus? An island that the Greeks say belong to them but the Turks also say it belongs to them. So they now divided it in two and what do we have? two countries who's relations have improved but still harbour a dislike of one another, this came after war and decades of hatred. So who would you give Cypress to? Greece or Turkey? both claim it as part of their homeland.

 

[winterinmoscow]

And what about those living in "Kurdistan" who are not Kurdish? What do you propose should be done about them? Or Kurdish people who do not live in Kurdistan and have no desire to do so.

Your whole argument is absurd unless you're willing to talk about the practical consequences of your "solution", which rests on the assumption that everybody wants to be in their historic "ethnic homeland".

^^^^^this^^^^^

 

[jimadore]

Sorry but this will never work.

 

[THINK!]

Africa is 3 times the size of Europe, and has around 50 countries. If you extrapolated, you would expect Africa to hav about 150 countries, but it too has only around 50 countries. Some of the countries are so obviously artificial and desperately in need of breaking up, like Sudan, i 'm surprised at the level of opposition.