Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

New Labours Great Betrayal

I knew we wouldn't be getting the 'socialism red in tooth and claw' of the failed Foot days but I certainly didn't expect them to be worse than the Tories who preceeded them.
Well, you should have read the pamphlets and articles I was writing at the time. They were very good; I was right about a lot of things, except I thought Frank Field would last longer.
 
Doubled spending on health and education.


Most of it lost in waste and PFI
The minimum wage.

A failed policy because it has become the Average wage rather than a minium. The import of cheap labour has undermined the idea of the min wage being an absolute minimum.
Sure start.

A success I grant you.

In what way are those policies wrose than the Tories that preceded them?

SureStart has been a success but the extra money to health has just been eaten up in junkets for senior management, servicing PFI contracts etc. Very little of it seems to have trickled down to patients. (Oi Brown wheres my fucking affordable Dentist you scumbag).

NL shot British workers in the back with the min wage by undermining it by allowing bosses to import shitloads of cheap labour. Its now not a bare minimum but an average wage.

NL have also continued the grabbing of ordinary pensioners savings by forcing them to sell their homes to pay for the care that they had previously paid out for WITH THEIR TAXES.

How can the Tories possibly be worse than this lot? Surely they've improved and reformed from the excesses of the past?
 
Doubled spending on health and education.
PFI/PPP.

The Minimum Income guarantee.
You're having a laugh.

The minimum wage.
Yes, we've covered that. It's a way of standardising labour costs, the industry standard in many sectors, fast becoming the mode wage, and not something to be proud of. And the Tories support it.

Sure start.
After 10 years, did it reduce child poverty? Hmmm?
 
The thing is that a lot of people do want socialism. But Socialism has come so mixed up in the public mind with weak minded liberalism that it does not appeal.
Most people are against the Orthodox lefts liberal views on crime and immigration because they know that those views are not based on reality but academic posturing.

This situation is not accidental though is it? It's a product of the way the ruling class manufactures consent.

Also, it's not as if the Right, even the far-Right is devoid of intellectuals. The idea that academic posturing is the sole preserve of the left is just more ruling-class propaganda.
 
This situation is not accidental though is it? It's a product of the way the ruling class manufactures consent.

Also, it's not as if the Right, even the far-Right is devoid of intellectuals. The idea that academic posturing is the sole preserve of the left is just more ruling-class propaganda.

The thing is the ruling class in the UK have hung on to power partly cos they have very much influenced the direction of the so called opposition....
You look at the far left in this country it has always been dominated and led by middle class people and middle class thinking.
People are encouraged to choose sides between shit rival ideologies rather than think for themselves....But still plenty do....plenty want to see less inequality but will never accept the lies of the liberal left on crime and immigration......
 
Most of it lost in waste and PFI

And how exactly is that different from when the tories were in power?

Private companies always made a fortune out of the NHS.
There were always a load of parasites creaming off money from health and education. The thing is that if you doubled spending on health and education the opportunities for these parasites will increase..
But how exactly would you or the tories stop it?
 
And how exactly is that different from when the tories were in power?

Although they didn't spend as much it seemed to be targetted much better.
Private companies always made a fortune out of the NHS.
There were always a load of parasites creaming off money from health and education. The thing is that if you doubled spending on health and education the opportunities for these parasites will increase..
But how exactly would you or the tories stop it?

I agree with you but what can you do? All you can really do is vote the govt out and sadly the only effective way of getting them out is to vote tory and hope that Labour clean out the augean stables whilst in opposition. Then and only then can they come back and say 'we've changed trust us'.
 
The thing is the ruling class in the UK have hung on to power partly cos they have very much influenced the direction of the so called opposition....
You look at the far left in this country it has always been dominated and led by middle class people and middle class thinking.
People are encouraged to choose sides between shit rival ideologies rather than think for themselves....But still plenty do....plenty want to see less inequality but will never accept the lies of the liberal left on crime and immigration......

I don't know about 'always'. There was plenty of w/c self-education, self-understanding etc previously, although there is more truth in what you say in terms of the present time. Still, things are not all bad - as long as the w/c can still think then there is hope yet.
 
Although they didn't spend as much it seemed to be targetted much better.

.

Have to disagree... The last Tory govt and Tory councils wasted billions on utter rubbish....Things like Training Enterprise councils etc etc were every bit as bad as shite like Primary Care trusts.....

The thing is that the Tory dominated media are much keener to point out when Labour wastes public money......
 
Have to disagree... The last Tory govt and Tory councils wasted billions on utter rubbish....Things like Training Enterprise councils etc etc were every bit as bad as shite like Primary Care trusts.....

You do have a point there. TEC's could have been a good thing but they were managed in a totally shit way.
The thing is that the Tory dominated media are much keener to point out when Labour wastes public money......

The problem is its not just the Tory press who point out the failings of NL its those who have to live under their boot. Living in Newham which is a one party NL state taught me that I never want to live in such a borough again. Corrupt, electorally dodgy, inefficient and much more. Many of those who moan about NL are moaning because of the piss poor way that they have been treated by NL not because they have been prompted by the Sun or the Mail etc.
 
You do have a point there. TEC's could have been a good thing but they were managed in a totally shit way.


The problem is its not just the Tory press who point out the failings of NL its those who have to live under their boot. Living in Newham which is a one party NL state taught me that I never want to live in such a borough again. Corrupt, electorally dodgy, inefficient and much more. Many of those who moan about NL are moaning because of the piss poor way that they have been treated by NL not because they have been prompted by the Sun or the Mail etc.

True im not really blaming it all on the media...Lots of Labour councils are worse than shit......But i bet if you looked into how some of the councils in the shires spent public money you would get a nasty shock...One party boroughs end up a bit like one party countrys full of shit and corruption....
 
True im not really blaming it all on the media...Lots of Labour councils are worse than shit......But i bet if you looked into how some of the councils in the shires spent public money you would get a nasty shock...One party boroughs end up a bit like one party countrys full of shit and corruption....

Yup. Its just my personal experience of crap and corrupt local govt was under NL. There are badly run Tory local councils and badly one Labour Lib Dem ones.

Fuck me I wish there was an alternative to having to vote Tory but there isn't .
 
You oppose Labour because they haven't built council houses, they supported a war in Iraq, and failed to live up to their credentials.

So your solution is, 'vote for a party who will do exactly the same as Labour, but potentially worse.'

There's something seriously wrong with you.
 
You oppose Labour because they haven't built council houses, they supported a war in Iraq, and failed to live up to their credentials.

So your solution is, 'vote for a party who will do exactly the same as Labour, but potentially worse.'

There's something seriously wrong with you.

But we voted for something better in '97, through to 05 and look what we've got? If you are going to have a shitty govt you might as well have one where you have no illusions about the fact they might be shit.
 
Why on earth do we get nonsense comments about voting tory not solving the problem.

The point of the thread is Labours betrayal - an open and shut case, not the merits or otherwise of the opposition.

While we have thinking like that we will have the neoliberal duoploy cartel.
 
Yawn!

There is no EFFECTIVE way to remove NL apart from a Tory vote.

Do pay attention then fuck off. :D

And what is the purpose of removing NL in order to replace them with the same or worse?

Aside from some fucking asinine juvenile bullshit about "at least the Tories are honest about crapping on you".

Is that really all you've got? Is that the best argument you can come up with after racking your brains?

Tory cunt.
 
The Tories will cut public services and cut taxes if elected. This alone puts clear blue water between them.

It is absurd to argue they are exactly the same, they are similar but there are differences.
 
The Tories will win the next election anyway, the people are incapable of thinking beyond a two party system. Its all about voting against something these days.
 
The Tories will cut public services and cut taxes if elected. This alone puts clear blue water between them.

It is absurd to argue they are exactly the same, they are similar but there are differences.

They are both a crock of shite and neither enjoys more than about 20% real support among the population.

They are a corrupt cartel, colluding in a phoney paradigm.

The chief rallying call in both cases is usually "vote for us, we're not them".

And a large enough minority fall for it every single time.
 
And what is the purpose of removing NL in order to replace them with the same or worse?

Aside from some fucking asinine juvenile bullshit about "at least the Tories are honest about crapping on you".

Is that really all you've got? Is that the best argument you can come up with after racking your brains?

Tory cunt.


If all you can do is call me a Tory cunt for questioning whether its correct to keep voting to get my arse kicked by NL then the only person pushing juvenille bullshit is your good self.
 
They are both a crock of shite and neither enjoys more than about 20% real support among the population.

They are a corrupt cartel, colluding in a phoney paradigm.

The chief rallying call in both cases is usually "vote for us, we're not them".

And a large enough minority fall for it every single time.

Labour may be a crock of shite taffboy but what is the alternative? I cant think of any political party that isnt even more shite to be honest.
 
Labour may be a crock of shite taffboy but what is the alternative? I cant think of any political party that isnt even more shite to be honest.

Yup you vote for the party that is the least worst. At the moment (and that could change) the Tories look like the least worst to me especially on the issue of personal freedoms (and remember its the British personal freedoms that attracted so many talented immigrants to the UK enriching us for decades) which New Labour have been so keen on trashing.
 
Back
Top Bottom