Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Nature is your new god

I don't think that political theorists have the same influence as people with power. it's power not theories that have power.

Thats only one side of the story. Ideas are very powerful things, they take hold and shape what happens. Whether powerful people promote them or attempt to destroy them, ideas are stubborn, they can become almost immortal, the closest thing to actual gods.
 
I don't think that political theorists have the same influence as people with power. it's power not theories that have power. capitalism was a 'concession', it will never change because of this imaginary thing like 'nature' just like we didn't get where we are because of this imaginary thing, unless you want to be reductionist, and then we might as well just all buy guns

what i'm trying to talk about is that people say things are 'natural' when nothing is natural to us, because what is natural to you isn't even natural to me and we are from the same country and agree about a lot

nothing is 'natural'. it's a made up word

There's no seperation between power and theory, in fact theory adapts and is guided by power.

Right, i agree with you, but your OP - come on? It doesn't say what you've been forced to say now. There's a good, interesting debate in there.
 
Yes. People sometimes talk about what they think is realistic due to 'human nature' though, thats still used to attempt to ridicule all sorts of political positions. I might be guilty of this occasionally because it is hard to think about how humanity might organise without drawing on our own expectations of humanity.

As for worshipping nature, at least this makes sense on one level, as we would not be doing so well without the planet or sun. If only the desire to worship and believe could be translated into protecting the things which we know are necessary to sustain life, we might be on to something?

that's kind of what i was saying

you'd never say 'it's the planet's way' or 'it's the will of the sun'

but that kind of makes as much sense as natural
 
but to say 'the sun' or 'by the force of exothermic reactions caused by halophilic bacteria' would imply that everyone should understand the process by which something occured, where as if you want to speak generally and include most people the term natural encompasses that.

some things are natural by the above examples....lots of things arent, or are debateably.

is there a specific exmaple that relates to your original post?
 
There's no seperation between power and theory, in fact theory adapts and is guided by power.

Right, i agree with you, but your OP - come on? It doesn't say what you've been forced to say now. There's a good, interesting debate in there.

well you know how i go on. yes the OP was rubbish, but it was just about throwing out an idea which we can all expand on
 
but to say 'the sun' or 'by the force of exothermic reactions caused by halophilic bacteria' would imply that everyone should understand the process by which something occured, where as if you want to speak generally and include most people the term natural encompasses that.

some things are natural by the above examples....lots of things arent, or are debateably.

is there a specific exmaple that relates to your original post?

i started the thread because i have heard lots of people of all political persuasions resort to 'well, it's natural, i mean look at.....'

and it isn't really fair, they are all natural

it's what you'd imagine of a political debate in the dark ages in europe and someone winning it by saying 'oh well god says....' and winning the argument like that
 
political stuff is all based on non-sense and 'one's opinion' and twisting stats and cherry picking facts to suit ones needs (maybe not intentionally).

does it suprise you that that is the case?
 
Most humans find God hard to comprehend. I dont find it hard - and i dont know why.

depends on how much God wants to show you. Im not sure we all see the exact same thing.
 
political stuff is all based on non-sense and 'one's opinion' and twisting stats and cherry picking facts to suit ones needs (maybe not intentionally).

does it suprise you that that is the case?

it doesn't surprise me, i was just saying

it's like how TV made politics from 1000 words into 5

i'm not starting a political party, I'm just saying something that occurs to me to talk about with people so we don't have to talk about halleluljah again :D
 
I ought to be good at editing, really, but terribly sorry to hvae destroyed the architectural beauty and simplicity of the previous ending, -- I had no idea, you didn't put up a sign saying keep off the grass,, and amen just means -so be it- apparently, it's a bit like "make it so".

Anyway, editing, yes, humour, no.

If everything's natural, then natural's a bit of a useless concept.
I don't know what this thread's about to be honest, I just rather agreed with what cheesy said, or to be both more exact and more pretentious, it resonated with me.
 
I'm not sure what this is supposed to be about really. I can't tell what arguments are being conflated here because, while I can think of quite a few which use "natural", none of them are really "leftie" ones.
 
I ought to be good at editing, really, but terribly sorry to hvae destroyed the architectural beauty and simplicity of the previous ending, -- I had no idea, you didn't put up a sign saying keep off the grass,, and amen just means -so be it- apparently, it's a bit like "make it so".

Anyway, editing, yes, humour, no.

If everything's natural, then natural's a bit of a useless concept.
I don't know what this thread's about to be honest, I just rather agreed with what cheesy said, or to be both more exact and more pretentious, it resonated with me.

Well the intangible beauty of this thread was created by me. and I'm gonna smite you for this :D

I was going to say that it was the best end of a thread ever, but then it wouldn't have been
 
Back
Top Bottom