Brainaddict said:
Over to you, Pie Face
London Bookgroup welcomes old and new members
- Thread starter onemonkey
- Start date
Over to you, Pie Face
Brainaddict said:
Jesus - I'll keep my mouth shut in future. I'm assuming from your lack of smileys you actually believe this then? You're a real martyr to your cause spending all this painful time talking about books with people who did degrees on literature.
Do you think we hold the reverse opinion?
Brainaddict
slight system overdrive
Well, I don't think you should take the absence of smilies to mean that it was entirely serious. On the other hand it isn't entirely not serious...PieEye said:
Anyway, I reckon that the further away people get from their literature degrees, the more able they are to talk about books like human beings - which is why I don't mind you lot too much
Brainaddict
slight system overdrive
<maintains a dignified silence>PieEye said:
PieEye said:
Fairplay - I knew it would irk you slightly but it was essentially a meaningless comment.
I'd take a second to think about what would have happened if I or OU had posted something like your statement about folk who hadn't studied literature.
Reverse snobbery ain't no better than the regular kind, Mr Dignified.
I'd be totally fucking mortified if anyone at BG thought I was trying to look clever at meets and for the record, I've never managed to read a James Joyce
Orang Utan
Maybe I like the misery
I was a literature student. I think you are talking bollocks.Brainaddict said:
Brainaddict
slight system overdrive
Hmm, I think you took it a little more seriously than I intended it - sorry for any offence caused.PieEye said:Fairplay - I knew it would irk you slightly but it was essentially a meaningless comment.
I'd take a second to think about what would have happened if I or OU had posted something like your statement about folk who hadn't studied literature.
Reverse snobbery ain't no better than the regular kind, Mr Dignified.
I'd be totally fucking mortified if anyone at BG thought I was trying to look clever at meets and for the record, I've never managed to read a James Joyce
But if I go along with your seriousness for a moment - those who haven't studied literature at university aren't necessarily in that state by choice, whereas those who have studied it obviously chose to - I therefore don't think that taking the piss out of those who've done it is as bad as taking the piss out of those who haven't
Orang Utan
Maybe I like the misery
PieEye said:I'd be totally fucking mortified if anyone at BG thought I was trying to look clever at meets and for the record, I've never managed to read a James Joyce
I managed Dubliners, but only cos it has some proper writing in it.
I never feel clever at BG meetings - I usually go the populist route compared to the others.
Brainaddict said:those who haven't studied literature at university aren't necessarily in that state by choice, whereas those who have studied it obviously chose to - I therefore don't think that taking the piss out of those who've done it is as bad as taking the piss out of those who haven't
This bit confuses me
Does it mean I chose to be joyless 
I've just re-read your OP - I think my knee jerked somewhat
Perhaps I'm worried about coming across as a wanky stooode. We need more Hollis in these situations.
onemonkey
winmonkey
as you can probably tell i am sciences graduate.. but my sister is an uber-literature student (who re-reads middlemarch at least once a year and is currently writing a literary biography ) i cannot think of anyone more enthusiastic about good books.
i think the kernel of truth to brainy's provocative sweeping generalization is that all sorts of people are overly impressed by any cleverness that validates their own modest talents..
the same could be said of unremarkable maths grads feeling like they can relate to einstein or newton
a lot of people will have studied literature because they were good at picking apart writing styles, spotting allusions and comparing X to Y... very rarely of course has the author intended to write in a particular style, steal particular themes, they just write what occurs to them.. and so it irks that 'literature' comes to be defined as a game.
but that is far from the whole picture.. lots of people just love 'good' books and a hell of a lot of the greatest of literature is genuinely great..
so on the whole.. i don't think 'liked by literature students' is a very useful yard-stick for rejecting book choices.
whereas 'it's a bit like the da vinci code' is perfect!
i think the kernel of truth to brainy's provocative sweeping generalization is that all sorts of people are overly impressed by any cleverness that validates their own modest talents..
the same could be said of unremarkable maths grads feeling like they can relate to einstein or newton
a lot of people will have studied literature because they were good at picking apart writing styles, spotting allusions and comparing X to Y... very rarely of course has the author intended to write in a particular style, steal particular themes, they just write what occurs to them.. and so it irks that 'literature' comes to be defined as a game.
but that is far from the whole picture.. lots of people just love 'good' books and a hell of a lot of the greatest of literature is genuinely great..
so on the whole.. i don't think 'liked by literature students' is a very useful yard-stick for rejecting book choices.
whereas 'it's a bit like the da vinci code' is perfect!
Brainaddict
slight system overdrive
me? nononono, you're thinking of someone elseonemonkey said:
spanglechick
High Empress of Dressing Up
oooh - glad i missed this one. i must score two demerits - not only an ex literature student, but a literature teacher 
eme
turn a frown upside down!
well I'm glad there's a mixture!
remember I said at the last bg I'd put up a thread about the Angela Carter play on? well I have! anyone fancy coming too? zora?
remember I said at the last bg I'd put up a thread about the Angela Carter play on? well I have! anyone fancy coming too? zora?
citydreams
on the road again
Hollis said:
Have they put you on another training course? ((Hollis))
citydreams
on the road again
Hollis said:I have been running the training course.. sunshine.
Does that include chosing the types of biscuits?
Brainaddict
slight system overdrive
Seems like it would be a good idea. We could go for the 15th perhaps, or if not then the 23rd. I'd go for the 15th.Hollis said:
Pickman's model
sunset spires and twilight woods
i want to keep it the 23rd.
i can't do wednesdays due to other commitments.
i can't do wednesdays due to other commitments.
Brainaddict
slight system overdrive
There was always going to be onePickman's model said:
