souljacker said:
My opininon is that the quality of the guitar is not super important for your first purchase. You can get a cheap one with a practice amp and a 'learn guitar' book for about £100 from you local music shop and that will get you up and running.
i completely disagree. the quality of the guitar, ok, is not super-important.. but don't buy a cheap amplifier. if your rig is incapable of making nice sound -- what's gonna motivate you to play it?! it's a major put-off you can really do without!
so i'd suggest acoustic; for these reasons:
1) cheaper in overall price
2) more rewarding sound than a crap electric rig
3) it's all you need to figure out whether or not it's for you
4) acoustics are harder to play (because you have to press down harder)
5) the strings are further apart
6) acoustic is sexy and cool
and several zillion other things too.
i'd also advise getting a cut-away; because as you develop your skills you'll want to play about with frets you can't reach on standard full-bodied acoustics. basically on a full-bodied you get an octave of notes per string to play.. on a cutaway you get an octave and a bit..
the benefit of a full-bodied is better projection of sound. if you go nylon-string then you'll probably want to go for this option.
in my opinion a crap sounding amp is completely worthless.
I'd also say that if you get an electric, you can crank up the volume and distortion and immediately sound pretty good. An acoustic wont mask your cock ups as well as a distorted electric sound.
you say that like it's a bad thing!
listen, if you are masking the sound; then the perfect little intricacies won't show up either..
and you'll get better slowly, because you can't even hear what you're doing..