Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

'Israel' tortures Palestinian prisoners. Report.

CyberRose said:
Ok I checked and as far as I could see the UVDA-Captain R trial is still ongoing (which I assume also answers the last question too)

I also found nothing where the ISM admit to doctoring photos just blog-type sites with that photo with the guy with no feet and the shadows the wrong way (similar to the sites about the fake Lebanon photos) But apparently the photos were taken off their site by Reuters (tho that's the word of an Israeli activist website, not Reuters)

There, can we stop arguing about it now?!

Ah, the problem here is that Rachamim specifically claimed the three above points, and further specified that he could produce evidence to definitively support those claims.

Grandma Death has, himself, established way prior to this that Rachamim's claims are baseless, yet Rachamim still insists that his evidence exists. Given his insistence on the veracity of his claims, it's incumbent on him to support them or otherwise admit he lied (therefore definitively providing proof to other posters of his degree of credibility with reference to the Israel/Palestine debate).

As it is we still have Rachamim insisting his evidence exists but refusing to provide it, much in the way a child who lied about owning a particular toy will, when questioned, insist that he can't find it, that he's lent it to someone, that he could show it to his questioner, but that he doesn't like the questioner's sweater so he won't.
 
If he admits he was wrong can we forget about it? Please? And have no mention of it again?

Rach18 - please just for the sake of the forum just say sorry that you were wrong or whatever!
 
CyberRose said:
Ok I checked and as far as I could see the UVDA-Captain R trial is still ongoing (which I assume also answers the last question too)

Indeed all the evidence I could find was the trial was still onoing. Thank you for corroborating that :)

The second part (that is the claim the producers of UVDA admitted their segement on Captain R was 'pure fantasy') Rach again still remains tight lipped on. Despite the ease with which anyone can view this he (and I) have been unable to locate such a confession.


I also found nothing where the ISM admit to doctoring photos

You wont find any. Its a rach 'fact' which means its totally unsubstantiated bullshit in laymans terms.

There is a well documented 'cock up' on the time scales of the photographs shown to Reuters. Nobody on this site is disputing that. What doesnt exist is a confession by the ISM leadership that they doctored the photos of corrie. Ive had that confirmed by several sources. Again rach remains tight lip as to his claims and the evidence to back them.
 
CyberRose said:
If he admits he was wrong can we forget about it? Please? And have no mention of it again?

Rach18 - please just for the sake of the forum just say sorry that you were wrong or whatever!

If I can wait 6 months with no evidence to back up his claims then I strongly suspect you'll be waiting a damn sight longer for a confession that he was indeed wrong.

But lets not mince words here-he is more than wrong. He lied to bolster his position. People who conduct themselves in such a manner lose the right to debate IMO.
 
The liarboy will be chuffed that he's still the centre of attention and with OTHER PEOPLE filling in the blanks for him.
 
Rose: But don't you see? My jumping through hoops will not solve anything. It is not even a matter of prinicple for me. I would certainly admit to anything to be able to enjoy valid discourse but this forum, and almost the site, is shot through to hell with people who are miserable.

Today I say "wrong," and tonight I will again be called every name in the book. Do you know the very first day I posted here I was cursed by 3 people, 2 of whom still post here . It is just the nature of of this forum. so, in short, I would not waste my time apologising for soemthing I have no place apologising for.

If these people really cared about these issues they would use their middle finger to either do a valid online search or very simply use their phone to call the relevant sources to satisfy their curiosity. The thing is, they do not even care enough to show me up! If they are so sure I am wrong they would so what I just said and prove it but instead they would much rather sit here calling names and acting like toddlers.

If I were the whining party I would simply call UVDA or better yet the Justice Ministry and ask for a fax. I would then scan it and gloat for however long it floated my boat. Calling names though is far better recreation for some.


I do appreciate you actually trying to find answers, I respect that but I do have to point out that you are at least partially wrong [altough unless I wish to stay on that treadmill I will keep it to myself].


I will respond to one of the miscreants today:

Panda: I did say I could provide proof and of course I can. Anyone can. All it take is a tad bit of effort. I also said that I would so when I finished with my service as I am too taxed for time. the reult? Cursed over and over and over. You are not better than the others. This is nothing but a game to people like you but I live and breathe this every day. So while you sit in England or wherever it is that you live, I will will continue living my life and putting convictions into actions.


It is my understanding that forums like this are created so that people of divergent opinion may meet and share their thoughts. It is also my understanding, and is in fact plainly stated by this site's administrators that expletives and ad hom attacks are not to be tolerated...and yet we have this nonsense.

I was called a liar before this issue ever came to light. I was cursed, as I have said, my very first post when I explained who I was and what my hopes for posting here were. Privately, in p.m.s, more than a few normal [relative term] have chided me for even imagining that civility could exist here and tsked tsked me for persisting in my innocently hoping. A couple of other "normal" people have pleaded with me to stay and continue to present a perspective that is often invisble on left leaning boards like this.

It has just occurred to me that posting here is a total waste of time and despite what a few nice people might say, the majority of people here would not behave differently if their requested sources were spoonfed to them. As I so often say, I am taxed for time. Ergo, I will leave this site to people like you to share each others' nearly identical opinions and total lack of subjective expereince and go on my merry way.

I will from time to time possibly post in other forums on this site but I will leave this forum alone because it is an utter waste. Rose, at least this should solve one problem, right?

To the board in general: I do hope that at least once in your lives you invest in an airline ticket and actually come here and expereince BOTH sides of a very complex situation. Nothing is ever vblack and white. good luck even to the nasty people.
 
Ergo, I will leave this site to people like you to share each others' nearly identical opinions and total lack of subjective expereince and go on my merry way.

I dare say that liarboy will dash hopes with a few comebacks before changing his mind . He's abandoned us 'nasty people' at least twice in the past seven months.
 
rachamim18 said:
Rose: But don't you see? My jumping through hoops will not solve anything.

Nobody is asking you to jump through hoops. After all this information is so readily available for all to see-so I repeat-there are no hoops and nobody is asking you to jump through these non existent hoops. All that is being asked is you substantiate the claims you made 6 months ago-please....pretty please. With a cherry on top.

If these people really cared about these issues they would use their middle finger to either do a valid online search

I have-and so (in case you missed it) did cyber rose. We couldnt find anything to back up your claims. So again-back to you. Its quite simple-this information is so easy to find, yet no one (apart from you), can appear to find it. Why is that Rach? Can it be cyber rose and I havent got a clue how to find information on the internet? Are you suggesting that?


I do appreciate you actually trying to find answers, I respect that but I do have to point out that you are at least partially wrong

Come on rach you arent getting away with that. Pray do tell which part of cyber rose's post is 'partially wrong' then?

rachamim18 said:
I will from time to time possibly post in other forums on this site but I will leave this forum alone because it is an utter waste. Rose, at least this should solve one problem, right?

Oh dear-as I expected. The inevitable flounce when the walls are closing in.:rolleyes:
 
rachamim18 said:
Rose: But don't you see? My jumping through hoops will not solve anything. It is not even a matter of prinicple for me. I would certainly admit to anything to be able to enjoy valid discourse but this forum, and almost the site, is shot through to hell with people who are miserable.
.


So ONCE again you have been asked to verify a claim you have made.....and guess what ...you have been found wanting yet again....same IDF story really.....no change there then.......next bulletain from the IDF on the way then i guess
 
rachamim18 said:
To the board in general: I do hope that at least once in your lives you invest in an airline ticket and actually come here and expereince BOTH sides of a very complex situation. Nothing is ever vblack and white. good luck even to the nasty people.
except those of us who have you call liars and say we are propagandaists when you yourself have been proved to be a yank miscrent... time in time out... shuffle off now laddie suffle off now...
 
Report accuses Shin Bet, police of severely torturing Palestinian suspects

By Nir Hasson, Haaretz Correspondent


A harsh report released Wednesday by the Public Committee Against Torture in Israel accuses the Shin Bet and police of instances of severe torture of Palestinian security suspects.

The report contains the testimonies of nine Palestinians who were arrested by the Israel Defense Forces and Shin between 2004 and 2005, including one that charged police investigators with committing severe sexual abuse.

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/865086.html



said the Shin Bet. "It is also important to emphasize that the information gathered during questioning allows [Israel] to thwart and prevent terror attacks and many civilians in Israel owe their lives to these activities."

I submit that a society which embraces torture for its survival is not worth saving.
 
Back
Top Bottom