Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Is Gordon Brown and the Labour Party fucked?

Is Gordon Brown and the Labour Party fucked?


  • Total voters
    52
MC5 said:
I see 14 Old Etonians that's 14 more than enough for me.

I have no axe to grind for Cameron, but I suspected that was untrue and a brief google of the shadow cabinet shows it's definitely not.

Leader of the Opposition: David Cameron MP. Eton
Shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer and General Election Campaign Coordinator: George Osborne MP St Pauls
Shadow Foreign Secretary: William Hague MP Comprehensive
Shadow Home Secretary: David Davis MP State Grammar
Shadow Secretary of State for Defence: Liam Fox MP Scottish High School
Shadow Secretary of State for Children, Schools and Families: Michael Gove MP State and Independent schools in Aberdeen
Shadow Secretary of State for Innovation, Universities and SkillsDavid Willetts MP: king edwards, independent grammar in Brum
Shadow Secretary of State for Health: Andrew Lansley MP Brentwood Sch, Essex
Shadow Secretary of State for Transport: Theresa Villiers MP can't find
Shadow Secretary of State for Justice: Nick Herbert MP Haileybury
Shadow Secretary of State for Work and Pensions: Chris Grayling MP RGS high wycombe (state)
Shadow Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs: Peter Ainsworth MP Ludgrove school
Shadow Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government: Eric Pickles MP Greenshead grammar school

I don't expect that the Labour cabinet would have that dissimilar a split, although I can't be arsed to google any more.
 
Yes nu labour sucks up to big buisness for donations but a lot of these donors don't like this to be made public i imagine for what we would call street cred ,they don't make these donation with out expecting something back.nu labour cannot carry on its right wing policies with the support it used to get because member support as diminshed because of disulusioned members have left the party and union support cannot be assured by their policies.So these underhand donation are the order of the day.i believe nu labour will have more and more problems raising finance that's why they favour state funding
 
Maurice Picarda said:
I have no axe to grind for Cameron, but I suspected that was untrue and a brief google of the shadow cabinet shows it's definitely not.

Leader of the Opposition: David Cameron MP. Eton
Shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer and General Election Campaign Coordinator: George Osborne MP St Pauls
Shadow Foreign Secretary: William Hague MP Comprehensive
Shadow Home Secretary: David Davis MP State Grammar
Shadow Secretary of State for Defence: Liam Fox MP Scottish High School
Shadow Secretary of State for Children, Schools and Families: Michael Gove MP State and Independent schools in Aberdeen
Shadow Secretary of State for Innovation, Universities and SkillsDavid Willetts MP: king edwards, independent grammar in Brum
Shadow Secretary of State for Health: Andrew Lansley MP Brentwood Sch, Essex
Shadow Secretary of State for Transport: Theresa Villiers MP can't find
Shadow Secretary of State for Justice: Nick Herbert MP Haileybury
Shadow Secretary of State for Work and Pensions: Chris Grayling MP RGS high wycombe (state)
Shadow Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs: Peter Ainsworth MP Ludgrove school
Shadow Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government: Eric Pickles MP Greenshead grammar school

I don't expect that the Labour cabinet would have that dissimilar a split, although I can't be arsed to google any more.

I suspect MC5 is referring to the reports last year that the shadow front bench team as a whole has 15 old etonians amongst it's ranks:

Hugo Swire: Culture, media and sport: Eton and St Andrews, Clubs White's, Pratt's, Beefsteak

Viscount Bridgeman: Home affairs, Eton, Beefsteak

David Cameron Leader: Eton and Oxford, White's

Bill Wiggin: Environment, Eton and Cambridge

Oliver Letwin: Head of policy, Eton and Cambridge

Viscount Astor: Culture, media and sport, Eton, White's, Turf

Boris Johnson: Higher education, Eton and Oxford, Beefsteak, Garrick

Lord de Mauley: Trade and industry, Eton

Geoffrey Clifton-Brown: Trade and industry, Eton and Royal Agricultural College, Cirencester

Lord Cope of Berkeley: Chief whip, Eton

Lord Glentoran: Northern Ireland, Eton and Grenoble University, France

Lord Skelmersdale: Work and pensions, Eton and Wandsworth College

Lord Luke: Culture, media and sport, Eton and Cambridge

Lord Astor of Hever: Defence, Eton

Story
 
So of the 130 offices that Cameron has in his gift from a base of 198 MPs and 202 lords temporal, he's given nine to MPs and six to lords from his old skool. And he's had the sense to keep all of them away from senior cabinet roles.

No, I'm going to need another reason to see Cameron as such a terrifying alternative that the Brown boat shouldn't be rocked.
 
this is part of the letter sent by mendolsohm to abrahams

At some point, I would like to have the opportunity to talk with you personally about what we are doing and our plans for the time between now and the next general election

mendelsohm says in his statement that he was not happy with the arrangement of proxy donations and wnated to discuss it with abraham my arse:o
 
Maurice Picarda said:
So of the 130 offices that Cameron has in his gift from a base of 198 MPs and 202 lords temporal, he's given nine to MPs and six to lords from his old skool. And he's had the sense to keep all of them away from senior cabinet roles.

No, I'm going to need another reason to see Cameron as such a terrifying alternative that the Brown boat shouldn't be rocked.

I wasn't offering it as a terrifying alternative but as confirmation of MC5's point above about old etonian doiminance of the shadow front bench. Having circa 12% of your frontbench team consisting of Old Etonians, above even the ratio of public shool pupils nationally as a whole, does go some way to backing that up. I think being placed in key positions in trade and industry, work and pensions, culture, Home office and defence is pretty significant as well. Not to mention the 3 directly in the cabinet that you yourself mentioned. I wonder what that % would look like if we inculded public and fee paying MPs and Lords in it?
 
Steve Booth said:
Ten years of New Labour have made them arrogant. The government spokesmen and women who went on TV saying that the loss of the data discs will not have any effect on the identity card scheme for example.

Just plough on regardless.
Governments have no need to do u-turns anymore as there's absolutely no means of applying any pressure on them to do so. "Don't want ID cards? What yer gonna do about it? How you gonna make us stop?" might as well be their response.
 
If Brown keeps getting hammered like that at PM's Question Time i reckon he is likely to chin someone

As ever in recent weeks, David Cameron softens him up to the glee of the Tory backbenches as they finally have a Labour PM they can best every Wednesday and Vince Cable delivers the telling question or killer blow

'Stalin to Mr Bean'

that one might stick.
 
Paulie Tandoori said:
I think Vince Cable has looked far superior to either of the challengers for the LD leadership tbf.

You're not alone there, but that said he has the luxury of being able to be more himself than if he really was leader...
 
Kid_Eternity said:
You're not alone there, but that said he has the luxury of being able to be more himself than if he really was leader...

and he also has the luxury of a govt shooting itself in the foot spectacularly each week.

but he has asked some intelligent, searching questions.
 
Caroline Flint's doing a pretty good job of defending herself on Question Time. So far she is the only person who seems to have come out fighting on this one - and the panel and the audience seem to be giving her credit for it (while tearing the Government to pieces.)
 
Flint is a NL toady scumbag of the highest degree, she has risen to the top by brown nosing all the way.

btw, Hain is in the frame now, couldn't happen to a nicer person, not. This man has ben in charge of a dept, the DWP, which is obsessed with benefit fraud and has hounded many innocent claimants.There is also a web of corruption to be unravelled between Hain, the DWP, the giant US insurance multinational, UNUM, and professor Mansel Aylward: Director of UnumProvident Centre for Psychosocial & Disability Research at Cardiff University and formerly DWP boss. But is anyone on the left interested?
 
Its unfair to compare brown with mr bean ,mr bean is much more resourceful he can drive a car seated on the roof with a couple of pieces of string,and many other makedo ideas
 
Why doesn't Flash call an election now - come on - not so big and hard now. It is going to get more messy. Bring back the 1970s classic Gordon is a Moron.

You reap what u sow and these fuckers are going to get it.
 
Actually in some made way that'd make sense to do, call one early in the new year, it's not like he's got anything to lose...
 
You're tying yourself up in madness of global fascism and a national govt, a suicidal PM, please, get a grip. You'll have labour govt for two more years, they'll use tried and test PR methods within that period. That's it. No stormtroopers.
 
Kid_Eternity said:
Sounds like Harman is fucked...
I find this very odd: She said in parliament that only people who she or her aids knew personally have contributed to her campaign; yet there were loans and there are dinner parties to pay off the loans, are all those people personally known as well?
 
treelover said:
David Abrahams in the Guardian today, he is appearing to play the 'working class lad made good' card.


http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/story/0,,2220218,00.html

Why every interview with Abrahams isnt prefixed with "Warning! This man has an aversion to the truth" I do not know, especially as its such a huge piece of this story.

While its enjoyable to see Labour in such a predicament (one entirely of its own making, of course) - the cynical part of my brain does fear that this is a planted story (the cluelessness of this being almost too much to believe and the fact that the Mail exposed it), with the aim of getting state funding for parties, something which is being commented on favourably in some places.

As for Cable, the sudden warming to him will by the media is somewhat surprising - he has been banging on about these and like issues (one remembers his damning attacks on both the Labour and Conservative inaction with regards to the BAe investigation). This of course shows the value of having MPs who are not mere party hacks / ex-councillors / lawyers; in short people who actually know what it is they harp on about.
 
Something really stinks about all this. On the one hand various sections of Labour have accepted money from David Abrahams and on the other media commentators have been conducting character assasinations against him. His money has been good enough for them, but they wouldn't want to be seen in public with him. In some ways it smacks of a set up, and I'm also worried if there isn't some sort of anti-semitic sub-text behind it too.
 
There does seem to be some kind of anti semtic sub text to all this (the whole he's a tool for Mossad being a case in point)...
 
Back
Top Bottom