Pavlik said:
you've got no idea what you're talking about mate so stfu.
dont judge me on a paragraph.
watching those beggar kids on my first trip broke my heart every single day but i learned a little bit more about it this time.
I agree that saying 'take your hands off me' sounds like something a victorian toff might say but it felt right at the time and it worked.
I've done exactly the same thing in India - that's not what I was criticising you for. It does break your heart - it's shit and there's nothing you can do about it, and that's very difficult to deal with. Not as difficult as actually living that life, though.
What I'm saying is that hardening yourself to the presence of beggars isn't the same thing as thinking they're all frauds and con-men. They ain't. They're normal people like you and me pretty much condemned by caste, and socio-economic accident of birth to a life of shitty grinding poverty.
Pavlik said:
I walked up that street a good few times with various indians and they never once got asked once for money but they always waited to see if i was going to give and when i didnt they said something short, sharp and to the point to the beggar and the beggar fucked off.
why should i be subjected to having someones filthy hands grabbing all over me if your average indian doesnt put up with it?
I'm not saying give them a fucking hug and empty your wallet - it's not nice being pawed by a dirty filthy smelly (often disfigured) person when you're walking down the street and I didn'tsay it was. Look at my point again - it's about understanding the wider social, cultural and political context and not sounding like a callous western cunt. Which you've managed to do twice on this thread, now. Most of the Indians I've talked to about this do what most people elsewhere in the world do - they give money to some beggars sometimes, when they feel like it, which is what I've always done in India and here (in India with the added caveat of making sure I'm not gonna get mobbed by hundreds of kids if I give to one beforeI reach into my pocket).
Pavlik said:
plus.. i bought them all the beggar kids a big bag of crisps each on the first day and then when i saw them later they were all hiding the crisps in their saris and telling the tourists they were starving. when the tourists werent looking, the kids were chilling out and having a laugh together. as soon as a tourist approached the kids put their long face on, and moaned about how terrible their life was.
OF COURSE they did. What would you do if you were a professional begar?!
Pavlik said:
i attempted to make friends with a few of them but the conversation always went back to 'give me money' they said they had no mothers or fathers so i asked if i could come and see where they live. they looked very shocked by that idea at first then just laughed it off.
You are too stupid for words if you can't see why this happened. What? Were you tryingto test them? Actually... are you just winding me up mate? If you are fair fucks to you - I bit the bait. If you're not. I fucking despair.
Pavlik said:
i watched as they arrived every morning with their boss and left at a certain time every evening. They're doing a job whether you believe it or not and personaly i prefer to give my money to a working kid who has enough respect for himself to have a wash in the morning
Yeah - if you actually read my first post (I mean actually read the words, one by one) you'll see I'm quite aware of the professionalisation of begging - that they're doing a job, and begging is an industry in India. But it ain't a very fucking nice job, and in many cases it's not much better than slavery or bonded labour for a beggarmaster (not much different to a pimp) who owns your ass FOR LIFE, and who (if you don't have enough cash at the end of the day will often give you a good fucking hiding. You see, it doesn't matter if you're bruised or disfigured after a beating. In fact it helps in some cases as people are more lkely to give you cash out of pity if you have some sort of visible disfigurement or loss of function.
All I was asking for is a little bit of understanding of the background, social, religious, and economic contexts in which begging (the begging industry) opperates in India - which was totally lacking in both your posts. If you don't give a fuck and can't be arsed to go beyond thinking they're all bad people out to con you out of the badness of their hearts I don't really care.
Truth is they might well be out to con you - but not out of badness. It's out of neccessity, it's because their shit lives depend on it, and it's because the more moeny they can make out of rich western tourists the more secure they will be that they'll have a square meal and somewhere to stay without having to take shit from their beggarmaster (slave master).
And I do know what I'm talking about, ta.