Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Gaza hit was 'technical failure'

rachamim18 said:
I will try an exercise here. In Israel, we have what is called "G'bbush." It is [usually] a 3 dat vetting process for elite units in our military. The first day is intellectual assesment, the second physical, and the third is the most interesting....psycho-social exercises. The exercises are of the ilk where you cannot possibly simply have a right or wrong answer or reaction. For example.....I will pose one that I was forced to deal with when I was a teen and I was vetted for a paticular training assignment.

Say you are ordered to enter a camp, erect a permieter, and then take down a house. Entering the house, you clear it as trained, hearding males into one room, females into another, and then do a thorough search of premises for escape routs and contraband, as well as hiding individuals.

What would you do, if you were tasked with clearing the second fllor, and as you enter the kitchen [kitchens in our part of the world are oftebn on the second floor] you seea 3 year old smiling girl, barefoot and dirty, with her finger on the pin of a grenade about to pull it. What do you do?

Please imagine you are in the exercise and imagine it is real, cause we happen to deal with situations like this more than you think.

If you do nothing, she will pull the pin, not only killing herself but killing all your platoon mates as well. If you shoot, you will kill an inncoent 3 year old girl, fa ce an inquest, perhaps criminal charges under the worst scenario, and with a doubt a roasting by know it all foreigners in the press,etc. [sound familiar].


What do you do? Please answer.

Its not something i can honestly reply to, I have never been in that situation, nor ever want to.
I am aware that very young children are forced (children do not have a proper conscience at that age) to be suicide bombs for terrorist groups and that age does not decide weather someone should be shot.
 
Moono: Forgive me, but what does your continuous linking to a paer have to do with my understanding, or lach there of, of it? Furthermore, what is your opinion on Dershowitz and Benes's rebuttals to it?


Bluestreak: Of course the old comparison to Nazis...wow! Have not heard that one spun before!!! How about this, raise an issue and I will offer my 2 shekels on it. I am not an apologist, in that I offer blnket defences of all Israeli policies and actions. IF and when I see something wrong, and I have/do, I make note of it and if a thread addresses it, I post. I do not, by the same token, offer blanket condemnation of Israel and its policies. Israel is a national entity, not the bogeymean.
 
moono said:
Lobster;
Nah, you can't compare a victim with his assailant just because he fights back.

well, if violence perpetrates violence , nobody is a victim except the non-involved.
 
well, that got a response at least. you are an apologist though, you just don't realise that. you think that you can stop hamas etc through violence despite years of history proving otherwise. you think that people who criticise you and israel think israel are some sort of bogeyman, or anti-semetic, when that isn't the case. *shrugs*
 
rachamim, Dershowitz is a plagiarist and Zionist who has been exposed more times than Big Sal the Brooklyn Gal.
 
Back
Top Bottom