Well I'm sure I read that 9 bar was the 'proper' pressure, either on here (probably written by you) or on some coffee site or other, or perhaps the coffee appreciation thread on LFGSS.com - thought I'd ask in case I imagined it... but Jesus... 15 bar sounds bloody excessive. WtF?!! 15 bar FFS!?!?!?
Well, pods need 11-12ish.
I'm not aware of any machine that'd actually churn out 15bar. Though a few places certainly advertise machines' pumps ratings, as a bit of a willy-waver to claw in the punters. ("14 bar pump!!! omg!!! I want that one!!!")
tbf, it's all about parameters, Herbie...
All you're looking at with x bar is how much pressure you're using to get x quantity of water through a packed-down puck. The higher the pressure, the more finely ground the coffee'll need to be (or the firmer the tamp).
There seems to be a fairly promising interaction at about 9 bar, 25-30s for 0.75-1.25ish floz out of 7ish g.
Lower pressures can produce some really, really interesting results too. My MCAL produces beautifully thin, delicate, nuanced shots that really bring out the flavours of a bean. Not a great deal of crema, but a genuinely unique shot. You wouldn't / couldn't get that at 9bar.
Equally, grinding too tight at 9bar can produce some really curious results. I've had 40-50s shots that've been beyond awesome. Some of the best shots of my life have been cock-ups - including a 42 second beauty late last week.
If it takes 40s to pour, it has - clearly - been ground too fine, or tamped too tight. Yet that self-same puck would (presumably) produce a similar volume of liquid in 25-30 seconds if the machine was running at a higher pressure.
Yet IME that just doesn't work. I'm guessing there's something about the fineness of the particles and the speed at which they're stripped of their oils / flavours that tends to need longer to brew (i.e. 9bar, 42s). And that beyond a certain pressure, the pressure / grind equation just stops working.
I guess there might be something in that that means that... if the grind is right for 12 bar, the shot is going to taste thin / bitter / foul. And if the grind is wrong for 12 bar, then the shot is
still going to taste thin / acidic / foul.
*shrugs*