Do you consider yourself an audiophile?

Discussion in 'music, bands, clubs & festies' started by Doctor Carrot, Apr 5, 2010.


Are you an audiophile?

  1. Yes

    26 vote(s)
  2. No

    72 vote(s)
  3. Audiophiles are deluded bullshitters

    103 vote(s)
  1. newbie

    newbie undisambiguated

    not necessarily. Professional analogue interconnection is all balanced but grounding schemes vary, some installations carry all drains through, others break them, either in the XLR etc or at jackfields or Krone frames.

    I'm afraid I don't get what these cables are for. Standard length is 1m, the longest on offer is 5m. What use is that?
  2. beesonthewhatnow

    beesonthewhatnow going deaf for a living

    A DI box uses a transformer to pass the signal, so the earth connection is broken.
    existentialist likes this.
  3. ViolentPanda

    ViolentPanda Hardly getting over it.

    Sometimes, sometimes not.
  4. existentialist

    existentialist Girly swot

    Depends. My main area of expertise here is acoustic instruments, where design, quality of materials, and quality of manufacture play a significant part in both the cost and the quality of the instrument.

    At my level of playing, I know that I could quite easily tell the difference between a £100, £1000, £10000, and £30000 violin (I know this because we had a little game amongst a bunch of us once to pick them out) . The higher-priced two were harder for me to tell apart, so I'm not confident I'd be able to, say, pick out a £2m Stradivarius. Indeed, I gather that some top spec instruments sound worse in the hands of less experienced players, so the Strad might be harder for me to play as well as the £1000 one. But, played by an expert, it is not hard to identify the qualities of a really good (ie., expensive) instrument.

    And it is quite surprising how closely cost correlates with quality. In the test above, the £1000 fiddle was mine - given (lent, really) to me by my dad - a 1796 German effort that was probably made as a "pit fiddle" to be owned by a theatre. It caused some confusion amongst other players, as it plays like a much better instruments, perhaps one 2-5 times its value. The reason for that is that its valuation is very low (hence the reason my dad had it - he paid £40 for it in 1973),because it had been badly damaged, and repaired well enough, but not cosmetically. So it served a a handy blind in our unscientific test.

    With electric instruments, I cannot see how the same might not prevail - there is still a lot of scope for quality of manufacture and materials there, too.

    And remember that the user base for higher end musical instruments already has a high degree of training and skill, so are less likely to be misled by marketing dazzlement over practical, subjective listening, and I bet that's as true of Strats as it is of Strads.
    Ming and beesonthewhatnow like this.
  5. 8ball

    8ball Hetero Sapiens

    I doubt it happens that often in the low.second hand to mid price range. Most people I know who play instruments don't have that much money, and will want a good reason to shell out the cash. Though you do get a certain kind of middle-aged male who collects guitars as a hobby and likely doesn't play them all, or know their instruments that well.

    Sometimes there are subjective preferences, obviously, but usually people who aren't totally cloth-eared can tell the difference between a good and a mediocre instrument (which does not always fall along price lines, as any fule kno).

    The major caveat would be that when you get to silly money, then like with anything, it becomes about the money, which is really about status. I once played an expensive piano (a make I didn't know), and the owner would not believe one of the pedals did not work because she had paid so much for instrument and just had it tuned.
  6. existentialist

    existentialist Girly swot

    There are people who will buy an expensive musical instrument purely for the cachet of owning one, but in the musical circles in which I move, people playing expensive instruments are playing them because they're good, not because they're The Name To Have.

    The Strads and Guarneris are not usually owned by the musicians who play them, but are on long-term loan to them - there is little point in someone owning such an instrument if it is not being played, and most people interested in buying such instruments will know this.
  7. 8ball

    8ball Hetero Sapiens

    Well yeah, when you're talking about the long-term loans and the people who have mortgages and massive insurance policies on things then that's another different thing. Usually classical stuff ime. And the odd folkie here and there, though you get some of those who will play any old thing.

    Lots of differences compared to the audiophile world. Maybe it's because with playing an intrument you're a much more active agent than just being a consumer...
  8. existentialist

    existentialist Girly swot

    Yes, definitely the latter, and I was talking more from my experience as a "classically" trained musician. But the same would apply to my more musicianly rock/blues/jazz colleagues, albeit at somewhat lower levels of price.
  9. Cid

    Cid 嗯嗯

    Iirc blind tests have shown violins made by modern luthiers can match or er... outperform Strads. I don't know how well designed tests have been though... And these are top end contemporary luthiers, i.e anywhere from 15-60k Euro.

    No personal experience, just my cousin plays professionally in a good (classical) string quartet (and a piano trio). I think he owns his, dunno what it is though. Certainly he couldn't have bought it without relative death windfall.
  10. xenon

    xenon A move in any direction

    I've only played two expensive electric guitars. A PRS Custom 21 and Ibanez JS 1000. The latter I have owned for about 10 years thus know it very well. Put simply they just feel easier to play. More tonal subtlety and variety and balance. Compared with my cheaper Ibanez, it sings rather than screams.

    That said, even if I ever had the money I don't think I would ever buy a multi thousand pound vintage Fender, for example. Law of diminishing returns and at that level it's more about collectors item value as you say.

    So called budget electric guitars these days are really very good though in terms of build quality. They can just lack a bit when it comes to the pickups and electronics.
  11. existentialist

    existentialist Girly swot

    Aha. So perhaps my perceived inability to tell the difference at that price/quality range isn't just down to my competence.

    I'm not surprised; ultimately, a good musical instrument is going to be about materials, design, and execution, just like good audio equipment. If you can accurately manufacture something to a proven design (a lot of modern violin makers still use tables of dimensions from Antonio Stradivarius), precisely, and with equally good materials, I don't see why it shouldn't be indistinguishable from a top notch hand made one.
  12. 8ball

    8ball Hetero Sapiens

    Some of that might be down to the actual makes you quoted and personal preference. I've found PRS and Ibanez guitars have a fretboard profile that is great for playing rock stuff.

    Conversely, I don't get on with Strats and a mate of mine's Dad has a lovely old one. I still don't like playing it because of the horrible neck. To my ears it only sounds 'good- ish' too.

    Re: electronics and build quality, I think you're right - buying a cheap guitar then changing the pick ups is a great way to get a pretty good noise without paying too much.

    ATOMIC SUPLEX Member Since: 1985 Post Count: 3

    My two most expensive guitars are shit. Fender tele 72 deluxe. Badly attached fat neck and crap pick ups. £4000.
    8ball likes this.
  14. newbie

    newbie undisambiguated

    That's too sweeping isn't it? Pushing air around to make people happy, which is a what an instrument does, is somewhat more challenging than the design, component selection and calibration of electronics. The art of the maker may lean heavily on science, but it's art none the less, because each instrument has personality, revealed by the beauty created when a sensitive musician bonds with their instrument. Or so they say, I'm no musician. When a piece of audio equipment fails you just bung another one in, check the line up and fo to the pub. Even back in the days of huge analogue desks, when getting the lineup consistent across all the channels and groups was a major task, there wasn't much art involved until the final user got their hands on it.

    As for bits of wire, I see no art whatsoever there.
  15. mrs quoad

    mrs quoad Well-Known Member

  16. Orang Utan

    Orang Utan knows how to use the three shells

  17. Beats & Pieces

    Beats & Pieces 24601 / 9430 Banned

  18. hash tag

    hash tag member

    The easiest way to get this is listen to something played by Seasick Steve and soemthing played a more "discerning" musician.
  19. Ming

    Ming Massive prawns

  20. rutabowa

    rutabowa LOSE IT

    I dunno if those work but I'm sure 3D audio is possible, I was more questioning their claim that you will hear "music as the artist intended it". For gaming, where I guess the makers could specially make 3D sound in the game, I could see it working.
    Ming likes this.
  21. beesonthewhatnow

    beesonthewhatnow going deaf for a living

    Ming likes this.
  22. ska invita

    ska invita back on the other side

    3d audio is technically impossible with a left and right headphone - you need more than 2 sources, but there are ways you can give an impression of 3d with clever reverb-based plugins. but i cant see how the hardware would do that - thats in the mix surely
    ive just watched the video from that - with headphones on

    seems to me its just a crap "3d" plugin with a bunch of hardwear bundled in to the deal
    Ming likes this.
  23. beesonthewhatnow

    beesonthewhatnow going deaf for a living

    No, it's very far from crap. Let's imagine a performer on stage. The bass player is too his left, guitarist to the right, drums behind. So when setting up and IEM mix I'd pan stuff accordingly, so they hear things in the ears as they see them.

    But if they move that imagining is now incorrect. Use the Klang stuff with head tracking and the mix can move around as the performer does.
  24. ska invita

    ska invita back on the other side

    ah, that sounds clever
  25. Crispy

    Crispy The following psytrance is baṉned: All

    This is a real solution to a real problem. 3D positional audio can be done in software, but they have to use a generic filter for the "average" ear shape. If you can calibrate the filter so that it exactly matches the effect of the wearer's ear, then you'll get more accurate positioning.
    beesonthewhatnow likes this.
  26. rutabowa

    rutabowa LOSE IT

    that isn't going to make records sound more "like the artist intended" though. from a music perspective.
  27. Crispy

    Crispy The following psytrance is baṉned: All

    Correct, it's pointless for music (unless you want to make it sound like the music is coming from "over there" no matter which way you turn your head).
  28. rutabowa

    rutabowa LOSE IT

    it's not really the kind of thing that appeals to hifi freaks anyway though so probably doesn't belong on this thread.
  29. Ming

    Ming Massive prawns

    Thanks for the replies. I've paid for a pair as they're on offer at the mo'. Not for delivery till next May though. Have to admit i bought them for the Vive rather than music listening.
  30. Enviro

    Enviro Make your assessment

    Anyone seen these EVEN headphones? They're supposed to account for variations in your sensitivity to different frequencies to provide a better experience. I'm suspicious about this. Could be good for people with real issues, but for general use it seems a bit un-necessary.

    EVEN Earphones. Get Your EarPrint

    I'm sure they will sell though, with all that individualistic 'your ears are unique, you're a special snow flake!' type spiel.

    Reading the FAQ it sounds like the system is an all in one audiometry system that applies a filter based on the results - sounds quite interesting.
    ringo likes this.

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice