Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Deport sucide bombers' families?

tbaldwin said:
And they are 100% sure of what could have happened are they..Pathetic...
Don't be a twat. When can we ever be 100% sure of anything. But you can, and do, have people analysising phenonoma (you know like on this thread).
Your argument is so utterly stupid that if true it would render any political theory useless as you could never be 100% sure what would happen. :rolleyes:
 
tbaldwin said:
And they are 100% sure of what could have happened are they..Pathetic...

Well, no-one can prove a negative so that's a pretty empty fucking argument you've got hold of there. Does it go anywhere or are you just going to jump up and down on this one point? What evidence if any is there that a less revenge based policy against the Palestinians would have produced the same amount or more suicide bombs?
 
maomao said:
Well, no-one can prove a negative so that's a pretty empty fucking argument you've got hold of there. Does it go anywhere or are you just going to jump up and down on this one point? What evidence if any is there that a less revenge based policy against the Palestinians would have produced the same amount or more suicide bombs?


No conclusive evidence either way is there.
 
tbaldwin said:
To contradict some very arrogant people?

Rather than to try to make some sense of an escalating worldwide situation which continues to engulf countless lives?

I'm amazed. :rolleyes:
 
Originally Posted by Passepartout
--------------------------------------
Suicide bombers may not care for their own lives... but even they still love their families.
If the first response to the suicide bombers' attack is to deport their families -- down to the most distant relatives -- the next confused, disaffected, easily-manipulated teenagers coming down the suicide bomber assembly line might give second thought to their ghoulish plans.

Yeah.

We could bulldoze their houses too, like they do in Gaza...

:rolleyes:

Cunt.
 
Passepartout said:
Suicide bombers may not care for their own lives... but even they still love their families. If the first response to the suicide bombers' attack is to deport their families -- down to the most distant relatives -- the next confused, disaffected, easily-manipulated teenagers coming down the suicide bomber assembly line might give second thought to their ghoulish plans.

It's not fair, but it would work.

Unless, of course, part of the impetus behind becoming a suicide bomber is anger at one's family, etc.
 
tbaldwin said:
Precision punishemnt is always best. But not always that easy is it.
A lot of Geramns were killed in WW2 who didnt support Hitler etc..

That wasn't punishment though was it? War isn't two sides taking turns punishing each other.
 
Passepartout said:
Suicide bombers may not care for their own lives... but even they still love their families. If the first response to the suicide bombers' attack is to deport their families -- down to the most distant relatives -- the next confused, disaffected, easily-manipulated teenagers coming down the suicide bomber assembly line might give second thought to their ghoulish plans.

It's not fair, but it would work.

I've just noticed this thread.

This is Britain, not Israel. Here we respect the rights of the innocent.
 
Leeds town centre tomorrow:

bulldozer2.jpg
 
laptop said:
Oddly enough, this evening I came across fundamentalist Hindu article that proposed killing suicide bombers' families.

You don't think...

Jesus H fucking Christ, what's wrong with these people? They can't think any further ahead than 5 minutes, can they?
 
Originally Posted by Passepartout
I was serious, and nobody has explained why it *wouldn't* work other than hurling hyperbole.

Er... that's not how it works. You are the one proposing an extreme and (currently) illegal and certainly, well, let's say "UnBritish" measure, so YOU are the one who has to prove that it will work.

This is what we in real life like to refer to as "logic"....
 
I wonder if the thread starter has lost someone or something? People say things in grief and anger they don't always mean. Or they could just be an extreme right winger... Possibly a BNP type?

The important thing is to keep a level head.

Was just reading something on BBC to the effect that the suicide bombers are generally glassy eyed dupes, true programmed killers in the classic "hashishim" (asassin) mode- they've basically been brainwashed by a wierd cult into doing this. The article said how the people to go after are the controllers, the people who activate and run the bombers, because they do not want to die and therfore can be caught while doing dry runs, recces, and so forth.

In fact a large part of the controller's job is to keep the would-be assasin / terrorist gee'd up in a state of sufficient religious fervour that they don't back out. Cynical, no?

I'm not being "soft", btw- IMHO people like that, evil, dirty old men who take all of a young person's energy and drive and use it to turn the kids into walking bombs, deserve to be executed in as painful and unpleasant a manner as possible. But you have to catch them first...

Do you see what I mean, thread starter? The point of successful criminological measures is to find the people who actually did the crime, and punish them, not yet more hapless bystanders.
 
well leeds would be a pretty good choice imho for internal exile :rolleyes:
The bombers are already dead probably want to lash out at someone .
 
badnewswade said:
generally glassy eyed dupes, true programmed killers in the classic "hashishim" (asassin) mode- they've basically been brainwashed by a wierd cult into doing this..
Sounds like the type of people who support the wars in 'Raq and 'Stan.
 
badnewswade said:
I wonder if the thread starter has lost someone or something? People say things in grief and anger they don't always mean. Or they could just be an extreme right winger... Possibly a BNP type?

The threadstarter gives their location as Washington, DC. Funnily enough I commented the other day that the only nasty, vindictive "let's hurt these scum as much as possible" post I'd seen on a thread about the bombs in London was from someone posting from the good ol' US of A.

I draw no conclusions, but I note the conincidence.
 
I bet Passepartout's a christian fundamentalist - all the stuff in the bible about punishing families, yea, even unto the tenth generation. Ironically, if they sat down for a cup of tea with the islamists, they'd find they had an awful lot in common.
 
I think we should be careful not to sacrifice our own humanity and compassion to the hatred and fear that surrounds us - otherwise we will have lost and 'they' will have won, without barely even fighting.

fanta said:
It is quite a brilliant idea, but...
<snip>
...asinine knee-jerk reactions to the recent atrocities...
- nice attempt to invoke Goodwin's, fanta! ;)
 
Back
Top Bottom