Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Camp for Climate Action

In Bloom said:
I'm kind of tanked up atm, so I really can't be arsed going into a long explanation, BUT, for a movement to grow it has to be outward looking and address people's concerns. Just focusing on climate change is not enough.
Just focussing on id cards is not enough either.

But it is not an either/or thing is it?

We need lots of campaigns on a whole range of things. There is no need for one single overarching and monopolising organisation and there is no need to focus on only one issue.

Admit it, you just don't like camping do you?
 
TeeJay said:
Just focussing on id cards is not enough either.

But it is not an either/or thing is it?

We need lots of campaigns on a whole range of things. There is no need for one single overarching and monopolising organisation and there is no need to focus on only one issue.

Admit it, you just don't like camping do you?
Lots of isolated, single issue campaigns will achieve very little. Without a genuine, popular social movement, real change is impossible.
 
The Climate Camp site server got hacked a couple of days ago, and although they've managed to get it back up now, the forum's been completly destroyed. :confused: :(
 
Just for the record, the last thing that my parents (energy wasting, 2-car owning, Times-reading middle englanders) want to do is share their cooking with 200 other people, give up their cars or 'make the house look ugly' with wind turbines and solar cells. They are the people who need to change their ways, and "a bunch of hippies" (their vocab) getting together to do all those things isn't going to change their mind one bit (even though I personally would love to live like this). Only when it becomes too expensive to run those cars, when it becomes profitable to install home power generation will they change. And, in my opinion, no amount of campaigning is going to make that happen, because it would require the wholesale dismantling of the consumerist-captitalist system, which has more power than God. Peak oil and the following crash might wake them up, however. Revolution happens at crunch points, and I think there's one coming.
 
aurora green said:
Actually, I think that day's coming really soon.

Yeah, I reckon too. It'll require a little bit of social change. Just enough for the colour supplements to start talking about it.

Putting the boot up the construction industry wouldn't be a bad thing either...
 
In Bloom - you've not half shown up your utter ignorance of climate change on this thread, now don't get me wrong I'm against ID cards, and generally in favour of social centres and pretty much all the campains you're on about, but they aren't the be all and end all of it by a long way.

You appear to be of the belief that climate change is some fancy notion that even if it happes won't affect people at all (is it just british people you're interested in or are we allowed to include the rest of the world in this too?). What you fail to understand is that as with most things it's the poor generally who'll get shafted the most by climate change both in the UK and worldwide, basically because the rich have the money and influence to buy their way out of trouble / move to a better area / pay more expensive food prices etc. if they need to.

This ain't just about fucking polar bears you muppet, what do you think is likely to happen to the 6 billion people on this planet if in the space of a century global temperatures increase by say 5 degrees, leading to way more frequent el nino effects (and consequently way more frequent global crop failures, severe droughts, flash floods etc), more frequent and more severe hurricanes, higher sea levels, huge changes in weather patterns, increased storm severity etc.

you think it's just the polar bears?

Ok so how about the millions of people in the UK who're likely to see their homes flooded over the next century as once in a millenium scale flash floods become once in 50 year phenominums due to the increase moisture levels in the warmer air (obviously combined with daft planning decisions). And don't think that the insurance companies will cover them, because they won't - already the insurance comapanies are making allowances for increased storm severity as a result of global warming, and more and more houses are becoming virtually uninsurable. OR how about those living by the coast who's houses suddenlly become more vulnerable to coastal erosion as sea levels rise taking storm surges over sea defences... or just good old flooding from these higher storm surges. What about the 30,000 people who died in france last year as a result of the heatwave? what if that becomes the norm every summer?

get the picture? this is all about the affect global warming is going to have on people - only thing is that with this particular issue the people who've caused the majority of the problem will be the least affected by it in 2 ways...

firstly the rich who've caused most of the CO2 emmisions can afford to buy themselves out of trouble.

secondly most of the people who this will affect the most have not even been born yet, we're fucking up our children, grandshildrens and great grandchildrens environmental inheritance. Removing Co2 from the atmosphere, restoring permafrost, ice sheets etc. are virtual impossibilities, so we'd best hope that future generations appreciate all our efforts to change the world for them.

Now I'm only going to this trouble because I've always felt we were generally on the same page on most issues, & really don't understand your failure to get the whole climate change thing... basically if IMO if you give a shit about the worst off in society both here and globally, then you'd really better start thinking about campaigning on climate change or you're wasting your time.

As for whether the climate camp will do anything... I have my doubts too, but it's been a long time since there's been a proper get together of large numbers of campaigners from all over the UK specifically to plan the campaign against climate change, and if this is done right then it does offer a real opportunity for everyone involved to refocus, agree national priorities, co-ordinate action for maximum effect etc. IMO this camp isn't particularly about involving the wider community in the actual camp, it's about those currently involved in campaigning on this issue getting their act together in preperation for a much needed broadening of the campaign nationally over the next few years.

Out of interest on your single issue slant, do you think the campaign on cfc's in the late 80's was a successful one being as it managed to stop pretty much half the world ending up with skin cancer? or was it a failure because it wasn't run on anarchist principles & didn't really affect the working class of liverpool?

fs
 
free spirit said:
In Bloom - you've not half shown up your utter ignorance of climate change on this thread, now don't get me wrong I'm against ID cards, and generally in favour of social centres and pretty much all the campains you're on about, but they aren't the be all and end all of it by a long way.
Just a thought, but how about you go back and actually read what I said this time?

Maybe you could find the part where I said climate change was irrelevant or that it's something we should ignore, because I can't find that anywhere in any of my posts.
 
FAO Free Spirit.

You may want to read this post in particular before you call me any more names.
In Bloom said:
Firstly, the "save the polar bears" comment was in response to the moronic claim that "there's nothing else going on" and the environmentalism for itself approach of the sort of politics this climate camp is based upon.

As I have already said, my problems with this camp are that:
  1. Eco camps of this type have been done before, so there's no need to do this just to show that alternative, more sustainable ways of organising things are possible, without a particular reason to have the camp, it's a bit of a waste of time.
  2. It's just more insular, inward looking, activist milleu stuff, why just keep talking amongst ourselves if we're not going to talk to other people at the same time.

I'd be quite happy to respond to any criticisms you have of any activity I'm involved in, on a thread about those things. Again, this isn't about me.
 
In Bloom said:
Just a thought, but how about you go back and actually read what I said this time?

Maybe you could find the part where I said climate change was irrelevant or that it's something we should ignore, because I can't find that anywhere in any of my posts.

Nope, nothing, only ID cards/register, NHS privatisation, massive strikes over pensions and welfare "reforms" that are going to make a lot of people's lives a lot more difficuly.

Best just focus on saving the fucking polar bears, eh?

Of course it will, but I do find it quite telling that so many activist types put all their energy into campaigning on "the enviroment" or "Green issues" and go on and on about how "it could affect us too." Yet they never once deign to bother with the issues that affect people's day to day lives, the slow, grinding processes of alienation and exploitation that are fucking us all over. The things that you have to address as a movement if you ever want any significant degree of popular support.

ok so you never actually say 'climate change was irrelevant or that it's something we should ignore' but you've essentially spent the thread slagging off anyone who chooses to campaign on climate change because all the other issues you list are apparently more important and people should be focussing on these instead.
 
In Bloom said:
FAO Free Spirit.

You may want to read this post in particular before you call me any more names.

<snip>Firstly, the "save the polar bears" comment was in response to the moronic claim that "there's nothing else going on"<snip>

hmmm I think you may have misinterpreted what I was saying in my first post on this thread then
I'm not sure how effective it's going to be, but if it results in a more effective national climate change action network getting set up / re-established that's got to be positive really as there's bugger all effective happening at the moment.

I think it's fairly obvious that I'm talking about their being bugger all going effective happening in terms of climate change campaigning, not that there were no effective campaigns happening on any issue at all...

I'll try to be clearer next time eh :rolleyes:
 
free spirit said:
ok so you never actually say 'climate change was irrelevant or that it's something we should ignore' but you've essentially spent the thread slagging off anyone who chooses to campaign on climate change because all the other issues you list are apparently more important and people should be focussing on these instead.
Nope, not at all, I've criticised the Camp for Climate Action, that's it.
 
In Bloom said:
Nope, not at all, I've criticised the Camp for Climate Action, that's it.

hmm well that may have been your intention, but you've taken a few pot shots at environmentalists & climate change campaigners in this thread too... glad to hear you didn't mean to though :)
 
free spirit said:
hmm well that may have been your intention, but you've taken a few pot shots at environmentalists & climate change campaigners in this thread too... glad to hear you didn't mean to though :)
Is that cross heavy?
 
I have to agree with that. when i told my 2.4 kids nuclear family manager sister(though quite progressive) about the compost toilets at the Big Green Gathering and how they work, she was both amazed and horrified. She said she couldn't ever imagine using one. :D


though she does do a bit of recycling

Just for the record, the last thing that my parents (energy wasting, 2-car owning, Times-reading middle englanders) want to do is share their cooking with 200 other people, give up their cars or 'make the house look ugly' with wind turbines and solar cells. They are the people who need to change their ways, and "a bunch of hippies" (their vocab) getting together to do all those things isn't going to change their mind one bit (even though I personally would love to live like this).
 
London Meeting!

Climate camp comes to the big smoke for their June meeting...

Everyone is invited to come along and get involved:

* Date: Sat/Sun June 10-11
* Place: London
* Address: St Matt's, Bullivant Street, London E14 0ER (Nearest station: All Saints DLR)
* Times: Sat, 10:30am-6pm; Sun, 9:30am-5pm
* More info here

On the Saturday night there will be a launch party for Art Not Oil, 8pm till midnight.
 
Back
Top Bottom