Amazing Miracles of Islam

[Aldebaran]

explain what u mean by saying they were never intended to be historical records

I told you in the post you quoted. There never was intention to tell or write history. That they give a very lively record of that time period and the young umma is coincidental and can't be verified against other documents.
That is also the reason why the Hadith compilations are of such value for any historian who researches the history of Islam and in broader context the history of the Arabs and the Arabian peninsula; they are the only available existing source. Yet one can't do such study without keeping in mind the Traditions were not intended to give a historical record.

Are you done with the attempts to "insult" or do you plan to go on for an other day (or night, where I am.)

salaam.

 

[fattboy]

I told you in the post you quoted. There never was intention to tell or write history. That they give a very lively record of that time period and the young umma is coincidental and can't be verified against other documents.
That is also the reason why the Hadith compilations are of such value for any historian who researches the history of Islam and in broader context the history of the Arabs and the Arabian peninsula; they are the only available existing source. Yet one can't do such study without keeping in mind the Traditions were not intended to give a historical record.

Are you done with the attempts to "insult" or do you plan to go on for an other day (or night, where I am.)

salaam.

so they were written cos they had nothing better to do then

 

[Spion]

so they were written cos they had nothing better to do then

is that the only alternative to something being written as history?

Are you writing on here now intending it to be 'history'? Are legal documents at your local court intended as 'history'?

 

[Shippou-Sensei]

the illiad relates to historical confilcts but it is not history...

 

[fattboy]

so they were written cos they had nothing better to do then

they were written because sects like the rafideeh started appearing and fabricating narrations, so it became neccessary to verify and record the hadiths in books to preserve their authenticity.

 

[Kenny Vermouth]

salaam.

Fucking salami yourself.

 

[Allah]

Oh good grief!

Will you lot just knock it off.

Your constant, fruitless yapping has given me the mother and father of all headaches. You think your migraines are bad; imagine how it feels to have an omnipresent, omnipotent bastard-behind-the-eyes.


In order to save your pasty, wasted fingers from bruising themselves any further on your crumb-ridden keyboards, let me just clear something up:

fattboy is wrong. About pretty much everything really.

To tell the truth, I only put him on the boards to test you - it’s boring being a deity sometimes so we (yes, I said WE - and not in the Royal sense either...) like to fuck with you - but to be honest it has backfired a bit and the unrelenting blizzard of drivel spewing forth from his wretched being has started me questioning my own faith in me.

Look - I can’t promise anything, but I will take a few neurofen and - inshaMe - see if I can summon the energy to whistle up a little smiting lightening bolt or visit him with a plague of something green and runny if you promise to stop engaging with the silly man.

Oh and just for the record - those pillocks with the C4 waistcoats are nothing to do with me. You idiots made that up all on your own.



fattboy......I’m watching you........


salaam and all that.

 

[Crispy]

Very funny, but no alt. logins please

 

[The Groke]

Huh - I bet you are on His "to smite" list now.

 

[Badger Kitten]

Word to Allah.

 

[fattboy]

basheer al nar

 

[8ball]

How can Allah be banned?

He'll just log straight back in.

 

[Badger Kitten]

If he does, it will be an amazing miracle of Islam

 

[FridgeMagnet]

I just find it rather amusing that somebody is coming along and calling Aldebaran a crap Muslim. I mean, I've seen various criticisms of him by various people on this board but that's one I never expected.

 

[Aldebaran]

I just find it rather amusing that somebody is coming along and calling Aldebaran a crap Muslim. I mean, I've seen various criticisms of him by various people on this board but that's one I never expected.

I got a few telling me that I'm not a Muslim. Coming from non Muslims you surely understand that hurts.

salaam.

 

[rover07]

Typical Allah. Shouting his mouth off and throwing his weight about as usual...

 

[invisibleplanet]

An invisible, intangible, immortal, eternal G0D cannot be anthropomorphised (G0D made in image of man).

C'mon, urban75-G0D (Eloah/Allah) was smote swiftly by the mods - that couldn't happen to the real G0D

 

[Aldebaran]

An invisible, intangible, immortal, eternal G0D cannot be anthropomorphised (G0D made in image of man).

C'mon, urban75-G0D (Eloah/Allah) was smote swiftly by the mods - that couldn't happen to the real G0D

Unless that's what was wanted

I'm up again in the Dark Nights... But no fattboy to throw insults at me here. It feels almost as if I did something wrong that made me being neglected... or something.

salaam.

 

[david dissadent]

I only put him on the boards to test you -

He did a bad Job then.....



IGMC.