Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

A Voyage Around My Communist Father

I do think that having a notion of a different world provides it's own satisfaction. Human beings are always inventing little teleologies for themselves, whether it's romantic relationships, careers, dreams or all the rest. It isn't the intrinsic satisfaction that is necessarilly the most important thing, but the sense of direction/purpose.
 
You're right. I think it's significant that the OP went into the forces, rather than, say, becoming a City-slicker with the braces and the stripy shirt.

DownwardDog - I know this is a leading question, but would it be fair to say that you chose the RAF out of some idea that a person ought to do his or her bit, an idea you got from your da, even if you and he interpreted it very differently?

I think there was an element of that to it, but also I was determined to see more of the world than the gray vistas of a County Durham council estate and, I will admit, I wanted a career that would lead to a degree of affluence.

I've never been a very regular poster here and when I have I often been on the opposing side of some rancorous political debate but I just want to say that I really appreciate the obviously sincere expressions of sympathy on this thread.
 
He spent his entire adult life working for and oscillating between various Marxist-Leninist groups in UK politics. Even when I was too young to really understand the political context I was fully aware that he was unlike other fathers. Every evening would see him at our kitchen table pounding away on an old manual typewriter churning out endless letters to newspapers, pamphlets and articles.

He was an intelligent, literary and sensitive man who spent his entire working life earning a derisory wage as a hospital porter. He steadfastly and somewhat perversely refused to harness his significant gifts to advance his own fortunes. Consequently, he and my mother spent pretty much their entire adult lives, if not in poverty, then not far from it. When he returned from his National Service with the Army in Hong Kong he never travelled outside England again - his entire world was that typewriter, sparsely attended party meetings and occasional trip to Manchester or London for a slightly less sparsely attended meeting. My parents lived their whole married life for forty years in the same council house paying enough rent to buy it several times over. Their retirement was dominated and characterised by the petty tyranny of enforced economies and penny pinching.

Those of us with parents who were racist, money grabbing and reactionary might be tempted envy you slightly. You seem to have a (grudging) respect for your father that some of us will never have for our parents.

Your OP reminded me in a strange way of a song by Martin Simpson called "Never Any Good." in which a shiftless father unwittingly taught his son that there is more to life than holding down a 9 to 5, and being respectable and solid. He drew diffent conclusions to you, but there seems to be parallels.
 
Courtesy of wiki

Continuum: anything that goes through a gradual transition from one condition, to a different condition, without any abrupt changes or "discontinuities".

erm, my point, really. Revolution? Shuffling deck chairs.

Apart from things got alot worse from "27 'til after Stalin.

So JHE - were you kidding when you told me you idolise Enver Hoxha?
 
TBH, I think we can have the sectarian arguments on another thread.

The point here, and correct me if I'm wrong, is someone trying to come to terms with his father's life - a life he chose not to share. That's pretty difficult under any circumstances - political or no.

I really don't see this as a political issue. It's about questioning whether what your parents did has any meaning for your own life. As our parents die and we carry on and we try and find meaning in life in their absence it's only natural that we should ask these kinds of Q's. The political angle has a certain resonance for some of us, but you could just as well apply it to anyone who lived a certain kind of life that the majority in this unprincipled society would find difficult to understand...

I agree - my sympathies to Downwad Dog.

This is not the place for me to get my digs in against your old fella. he was dedicated and committed - even if both you and I may think he made some big mistakes in what he was committed to (for different reasons - me being being a trot and all :-). The reasons he chose that may have lost all validity after a while - but they were genuine enough when your parents started out on their path. And you old man's commitment was genuine.

As others have said - your mum and dad created an environment which helped bring up a thinking, critical person. For that alone they deserve a huge credit. Maybe the 'was it all a waste of time?' question can be best answered by saying that, maybe, it is not what you plan to achieve but what you actually achieve as a result of your taking that first path that is the important thing. You clearly care for your father and mother to, whatever regrets you may have for their lives, I think that stands as something they can be very proud of.
 
And what else is any kind of 'achievement' anyway? Would have have achieved more by utilising his energy and drive and focussing it on turning into some kind of obnoxious yuppie shit? From the sounds of it, though, that drive probably wouldn't have been able to have been focussed anywhere else. That's the thing about actually being passionate about something...
 
What, mine? It's fuckin' good an' all... indeed, perhaps it is award winning material... but 'Post of the Year'?

A little too prestigious. Gimme, 'Amazing Insight of the Month' or something.
 
a lovely post to read at the end of a long day, genuinely moving , reminds me of the obits of lifelong tankies that appear in my local paper Ham and High every now and again,many of whom fought in Spain, or on the streets of East London, but this was one was more personal and perfectly written - RIP commie dad, that is a life well lived IMO , definitely not squandered ,hopefully he knew that.
 
A touching tribute. Some of the finest people I have known (usually of a certain generation) were in the CPGB. Some left, some for other groups, or just gave up. But although the CP was never a mass party here like in other countries, it was the first introduction to working class politics for many, and achieved real gains in the authorities which they controlled, despite the other obvious shortcomings.

RIP commie dad
 
Maybe also focus on his role as a hospital porter. He must have seen a lot. Said many a kind supporting word to a patient. Taken care moving people or packages. Priceless conversations with passerbys. He may have been in exchange of ideas with others at work. A peoples person on the ground.
 
My father (see U75 passim) has been an unreconstructed tankie activist since he left the army in 1958 until a (doubtless CIA engineered) stroke felled him 4 years ago. This week he finally passed on to the great politburo in the sky and I thought it would be interesting if I briefly reflected on a whole lifetime spent in relentless far left political activism.

If you don't find this interesting or relevant please feel free to call me a Tory and move on to the next BNP thread.

He spent his entire adult life working for and oscillating between various Marxist-Leninist groups in UK politics. Even when I was too young to really understand the political context I was fully aware that he was unlike other fathers. Every evening would see him at our kitchen table pounding away on an old manual typewriter churning out endless letters to newspapers, pamphlets and articles.

He was an intelligent, literary and sensitive man who spent his entire working life earning a derisory wage as a hospital porter. He steadfastly and somewhat perversely refused to harness his significant gifts to advance his own fortunes. Consequently, he and my mother spent pretty much their entire adult lives, if not in poverty, then not far from it. When he returned from his National Service with the Army in Hong Kong he never travelled outside England again - his entire world was that typewriter, sparsely attended party meetings and occasional trip to Manchester or London for a slightly less sparsely attended meeting. My parents lived their whole married life for forty years in the same council house paying enough rent to buy it several times over. Their retirement was dominated and characterised by the petty tyranny of enforced economies and penny pinching.

I wish I could share with you a detailed expostion of the various organisations to which he pledged his fealty over the years but it was very complex and I lack the background knowledge to fully understand the organisational mitosis. I do recall that he was in CPGB until, I guess, the early 70s when some doctrinal split occured.

My own realisation of his mortality and how his politics has become a prison for him was one night in May 1984. We were both at the kitchen table,listening to the radio. Actually, he would have persisted with his anachronistic idiom and called it 'listening to the wireless in the back kitchen'. I was feverishly revising for my Maths A-level. I badly need to get an 'A' in order to obtain the RAF bursary about which I had not yet worked up the nerve to inform him. We listened together to the accounts of the day's festivities at Orgreave and he made a remark to effect that, "Well, that's it. That's as close as we are going to get." I knew that he meant that Orgreave was to be no Aurora and the revolution that he had spent almost 30 years working for and keenly anticipating was never going to happen. That was the first time I ever looked at my father and saw an old man.

And yet, He worked on, unabated for another twenty years after that night as the world for which he toiled slipped ever further from view. So how do we judge him? Did he squander his life in pursuit of an unworkable dream on behalf of a people who were indifferent, at best to his efforts? Or do we salute his idealistic persistence? I don't know.

RIP Comrade Dad

I haven't read anybody else's comments, just wanted to thank you for sharing that with us. In answer to your question, I suppose only you can answer that from your perspective. Likewise we will probably all have different views.

from a political perspective, I believe you make a political point which many people on here would do well to hark. You highlight how your father could have engaged his talents to provide quite successfully a more "comfortable life". He CHOSE not to. I observe this phenomena in almost all non-careerist politicals, and believe if politicals could acknowledge this almost universal truism, there might be a little less sectarianism on the left.

on a humanitarian and philosophical level, aren't we all 'squandering' our lives? how can any of us judge our own or anybody elsese life? I can only say from my own experience, politicals I have met who have reached a ripe old age whilst remaining politically active, do not seem to reach the same level of bitterness I see prevalent among many people of old age. In fact they seem to maintain a enthusiasm that I find delightful to behold. I hope your dad was in its category.

respect to you in dealing with your loss, ResistanceMP3
 
Back
Top Bottom