Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

"53% of energy from wind"

Article in The New Scientist today:

Wind power delivers too much to ignore

THE location of the British Isles at Europe's wild and windy western fringe does not always seem like a blessing. But in one important respect it is: the UK has the greatest potential for wind power, both onshore and offshore, of any European country.

Onshore wind power has expanded steadily across the UK in recent years and is a key plank of the country's commitment to greening its electricity supply. But as the turbines have gone up across the countryside, so has the level of opposition. Wind power has become a deeply divisive issue in British politics....
 
Doesnt the fact that over the year wind provided 12% of the power rather support the 'knock' that its too variable to provide more than a minority proportion of a counties electricity, rather than refute it? I mean it should not be in doubt that you can provide a larger proportion if you build enough turbines, but there is still a limit somewhere. That limit would be enough if we tailored our consumption to fit with these realities, and I can certainly imagine a future world where this happens, I just think we need to be careful with placing the wrong expectations on this stuff. Its a solution but not as we know it, which will be fine one day when the world only partly resembles the one we are so weary of today.
Instead of exporting electricity when the wind is blowing hard, build a series of hydro-electric facilities to use as batteries for when the power is needed.

Build lots more wind farms.

50% should be easily achievable.

Solar power where it is efficient (down south and on east-west facing roofs).

Something about MOX.
 
I think the 53% estimate is optimistic, to say the least:
Let’s be realistic. What fraction of the country can we really imagine covering with windmills? Maybe 10%? Then we conclude: if we covered the windiest 10% of the country with windmills (delivering 2 W/m2 ), we would be able to generate 20 kWh/d per person, which is half of the power used by driving an average fossil-fuel car 50 km per day. Britain’s onshore wind energy resource may be “huge,” but it’s evidently not as huge as our huge consumption. We’ll come to offshore wind later.

I should emphasize how generous an assumption I’m making. Let’s compare this estimate of British wind potential with current installed wind power worldwide. The windmills that would be required to provide the UK with 20 kWh/d per person amount to 50 times the entire wind hardware of Denmark; 7 times all the wind farms of Germany; and double the entire fleet of all wind turbines in the world.

...

To create 48 kWh per day of offshore wind per person in the UK would require 60 million tons of concrete and steel – one ton per person. Annual world steel production is about 1200 million tons, which is 0.2 tons per person in the world. During the second world war, American shipyards built 2751 Liberty ships, each containing 7000 tons of steel – that’s a total of 19 million tons of steel, or 0.1 tons per American. So the building of 60 million tons of wind turbines is not off the scale of achievability; but don’t kid yourself into thinking that it’s easy. Making this many windmills is as big a feat as building the Liberty ships.

For comparison, to make 48 kWh per day of nuclear power per person in the UK would require 8 million tons of steel and 0.14 million tons of concrete.
http://www.withouthotair.com
 
Isn't that the same as was being said ten years ago, only with an adjustment to account for the fact that we have a lot more already than was predicted to be possible then?
 
Except the 60 million tons of concrete and steel would be spread over the lifetime of the wind turbines, 20 years. 0.05 ton per person. Out by a factor of 20.

An electric car uses 1 kwh per 3 miles or 5 km. So 50km = 10kwh Out by a factor of 4.
 
Isn't that the same as was being said ten years ago, only with an adjustment to account for the fact that we have a lot more already than was predicted to be possible then?
No idea.
Sustainable Energy – Without The Hot Air was published in 2009.
 
Wind's been providing over 10% (5GW+) for the last 24 hours. I don't check very often but it's usually more like 3%

wind.jpg
 
Back
Top Bottom